Aside from TWDS1, what was their masterpiece game to you?
Yes yes yes. Walking Dead season 1 is a masterpiece that's haunting and uplifting and redefined yada yada yada.
But ASIDE from that game? What project of Telltale is their masterpiece?
For me the ultimate winner is Tales from the Borderlands. That game had fantastic performances, amazing music, a really solid sense of pacing and dramatic climaxes and it was genuinely funny in its setpieces, plot structure and sheer willingness to go crazy while keeping characters afloat.
Wolf among us holds a special place in my heart. The first episode was genius, the second episode was...deeply odd, the third and fourth were very solid (bloody mary!) and the finale gave us Bigby as the full on big bad wolf who actually huffed and puffed.
Season 2 of Batman was a personal favorite. It doesn't do anything overly innovative as a Telltale game or Batman game but good lord did they find a fresh and amazingly well done way to do The Joker.
What about you??? Aside from TWDS1, what games of Telltale have been masterpieces to you?