User Avatar Image

Fight Kenny or Talk Him Down?

posted by zgamer on - last edited - Viewed by 2.8K users
I am curious to see how people played out this scenario and why.

Personally, I took the talk down approach. Sure, we all want a little action and who better than the guy who prematurely killed an old man having a heart attack right? However, throughout Episode 3 it felt like they gave a lot more logic and reasoning behind his actions. There is clearly something on his mind he can't get past and it might even help him in the long run to deal with it. So I talked to him about it and I think I did the right thing personally.

I never felt Kenny was "a bad man." He can be too impulsive, but at his core I can feel he is a genuinely nice person. I am glad I stuck to that feeling.
33 Comments - Linear Discussion: Classic Style
  • That would be cruel to fight him.
    "Kenny get the hell in there and kill your walker son!"
  • Xarne;673428 said:
    That would be cruel to fight him.
    "Kenny get the hell in there and kill your walker son!"
    Agreed. That's why seeing the scene play out that direction just made me feel bad.
  • I talked him down, trying to relieve him from the guilt he had for thinking Shaun dying was his fault, and because I could understand where his anger was coming from. And also because I'm not the kind of person who likes to fight, really, so it seemed like a better path to me.
  • I talked him down too. Kenny is certainly not a bad guy, and what was running through his mind would definitley make him snappy and thoughtless, his son was infected. I like Kenny, but poor guy, he's been through so much crap.
  • I would explain why I talked him down but I think it's been pretty well described in this thread so far.
  • not gonna start a fight to try to convince someone to kill his son lol
  • I fought him, because I didn't pick the right choice to calm him down I guess..... lol

    Once he started swinging I just let him beat Lee down and get it out of his system....
  • DreadMagus;673512 said:
    I fought him, because I didn't pick the right choice to calm him down I guess..... lol

    Once he started swinging I just let him beat Lee down and get it out of his system....
    So they actually make you push buttons to fight? I figured they would do like they always do and let Lee get knocked down or out.
  • I had a cursor that I could move. I guess I was supposed to line it up with Kenny's face or something - but I couldn't bring myself to do it.
  • Ah, and so knowing the game no matter who won the fight Kenny stops the train and they both go to Duck with non swollen faces or other bruises from fighting in a tight inclosed space.
This discussion has been closed.