Faith: I gave her the money because I didn't want her to get in trouble with her pimp. So much for that...
Beauty & Beast: I had to tell Beauty that I couldn't lie if I didn't know what she was doing, so when Beast asked where she was, all I said was that I saw her pass by. Seemed like a throw-away moment, until I saw the trailer for this episode.
Toad or Lawrence: Went to Lawrence first. Failed horribly. When I got to Toad's, I got frustrated with the puzzle and discovered an "out" option that resulted in TJ legitimately being afraid of Bigby. That should lead to some very interesting places.
Prime Suspect: Silent.
Grendel: Tore his arm off. I kind of had to; I was in Big Bad Wolf mode. Interestingly enough, when Woody asked if he would get the same treatment, I picked "No," and got some interesting line of dialogue that I hoped would have triggered a "He'll remember that" prompt. I mean, wouldn't you if the person who just ripped the arm off a monster said that he won't do that to you if you were respectful and cooperated with him? I know I would.
Woody or Dee: I ran after Dee just because I believed Woody's confession more.
For me I gave Faith the money, I mean after what just happened it made sense, I did not tell Beast, I feel like I should have but it was likely for the best, I guessed it might be Dee, I went to Toads place because I thought he was in trouble, really wish I did not, I got Woody, I now wish I got Dee but oh well to late, and I did not tear off that guys arm, I mean really he got his throat cut, his eye cut, and a pool cube stabbed through his shoulder, I think that was enough.
These are my choices;
Faith: I gave the matchbook and money to Faith. Maybe I was just a real sucker at that moment, but it does feel good to do good favors. When I saw her head on those steps, I was like, "GASPS Aw, damn it."
Beauty and Beast: I lied to Beast. I felt bad about being a liar, but I promised Beauty I'd cover for her. I don't like lying, but I'm a man of my word. I just know that it's gonna come biting me in the ass for it later on.
Toad or Lawrence: It took me five minutes to decide, but I eventually chose Toad's apartment first. I thought that Lawrence wasn't gonna go anywhere and whatever was going on at Toad's would help with the case. I also called him out on all three of his lies. Can you say pants on fire?
Prime Suspect: I picked Dee and Dum as the suspects. I trusted my gut on that decision.
Grendel: I didn't rip off his arm. I was tempted, but I figured it wasn't gonna look good on my image and thought that walking away from the fight was the best thing to do.
Woody or Dee: I arrested Dee. I don't know if I should've, but I believed Woody when he started pleading the way he did. He ain't no genius and I don't think he did kill Faith. (That moment reminded me so much of the "Save Carley or Doug" moment in The Walking Dead Game.)
I went back to do a second playthrough, and now I went to Lawrence first and kept him from dying. I also picked Bluebeard as the prime suspect. I don't if I made the right choice or not, but hopefully we'll out find in the following episodes.
Faith : Gave her the money , though I regretted it when I wanted to pay for the whiskey xD
Beauty & Beast : Promised Beauty I'll help her , Said nothing to Beast (left the elevator doors close on me lol)
Toad and Lawrence : Went to Toad first , since I thought that the guy who's assaulting Toad's place definitely knows something about the murder.
Woody or Dee : I went after Woody , thinking that he might have more information to give (since he has contact with Faith from the very beginning). I regret it now ... Woody probably doesn't know Sheeeet.
Prime Suspect : Doesn't matter , it's nobody from that list anyway. I chose Bluebeard , since it looks like his M.O.
Grendel : Didn't rip his arm off ... my job as a Sheriff is to protect the fables , not mutilate them. Besides , Woody would've refused to cooperate afterwards.
I agree headshot, that final choice did feel like the Carley Doug choice in Walking Dead, only it fitted in more with the Wolf Among Us.
OKAY, so here's what I chose:
Faith: I gave her money. I didn't want her getting into trouble with whoever she owed money to, plus it seemed like the right thing to do at the time.
Beauty and Beast: I lied to Beast. I feel kind of bad for not telling him the truth, but I did promise Beauty that I wouldn't tell Beast.
Go to Toad or Lawrence: I went to Lawrence's first. I felt really bad for not going to Toad's, but I felt it was more important to try and find the killer that was loose in Fabletown, plus I thought Toad could have handled his dilemma by the time I got there. Apparently that wasn't the case. :P
Woody or Dee: I went after Dee. His and Dum's activities seemed more suspicious than Woody's. Plus I wanted bygones to be bygones with Woody. I can question him later if I meet up with him.
Prime Suspect: I was silent. I didn't feel there was enough information to pin the murder on someone.
Grendel: I didn't rip his arm off. I was tempted to though.
I was such an asshole in my playthrough, except to Faith and Snow I always started fights, lmao!
Faith:Gave her money, was hoping she would swing by my apartment
Beauty and Beast:Said I would promise to not tell Beast he was there
Toad and Lawrence: Went to Lawrence's
Woody or Dee: Dee, went to replay to try to see if THAT ENDING would change if I picked Woody. Nope
Prime Suspect: The tweedledee guy
Grendel: Ripped his arm off, because my bigby is a such an asshole
It was so badass ripping off Grendels arm, I don't think he will be happy later down the road, but that is what you get when you tell the Wolf he is a lap dog.
Faith: Such a weird choice, I gave her money so her pimp wouldn't hurt her.
Beauty & Beast: Kept Beauty's secret
Toad or Lawrence: Went to lawrences first and he shot himself lolol.
Prime Suspect: Blue beard, and snow agreed.
Grendel: Tore his arm off for the lulz
Woody or Dee: I wasn't going to let Dee get away again, and I don't think the woodsman did it
My second playthrough I ripped off the arm to see what would happen and felt bad about it because his crying was so pitiful lol
Faith: I gave her money
Beauty & Beast: Promised not to tell and lied to Beast. And i think i did the wrong thing
Toad or Lawrence: I went to Toad .I thought that he was in trouble
Prime Suspect: ran out of time.
Grendel: Tore his arm off . That guy was really fucking annoying thats way
Woody or Dee: I went after Dee. Mostly because he punched me and i already got a change to talk whit Woddy
Hey there. New to this forum.
Faith: Gave her money.
Beauty & Beast: Said I'd stay out of it and gave Beast the silent treatment by accident. Haha.
Toad or Lawrence: Even though I knew the outcome by watching a walkthrough on youtube, I went to Toad first. He sounded like he was in trouble, and it turned out he was (sorta).
Prime suspect: Dee. I don't think he (or Dum) did it, but they're definitely involved somehow. Plus he ran when he was discovered in Lawrences closet, and he threatened poor TJ and Mr. Toad. Also, he and Dum were clearly looking for something in Woody's apartment.
Grendel: Left him alone... But I did "glass" Woody earlier, mainly because I wanted to see what Bigby would do. ^_^
Woody or Dee: Dee. Partially to keep the Toads (sorta) safe, but also because I don't think Woody's the killer. He's violent, drunk and all sorts of things. But like others have said, he's too obvious.
Also, like I said, Dee and Dum are up to something. I want to know what.
The Woodsman seems kind of harmless when he is sober. He is just tired of living in a lie. I took him in because the twin bros were after him and I wanted to protect him. And he could be an useful intel too.
I'm a bit worried about Mr.Toad and his son. Dee is out there, so they could be in trouble. Though the dog which barks doesn't bite. (I hope)
Faith: Gave her my money.
Beauty and Beast: I said I wouldn't lie without knowing why, and told Beast she said not to tell him.
Toad and Lawrence: Toad.
Woody or Dee: Dee.
Prime Suspect: The guy that decapitated his brides.
Grendel: Walked away.
Faith:Didn't Give her the money. I Figured Bigby might need it later and ultimately I think Holly deserved it more after the brawl with Grendel.
Beauty and Beast: I told Beast. Beauty was acting suspicious and Beast seemed worried, figured he deserved to know.
Lawrence or Toad: Went to Lawrence first and it seems to have been the right choice.
Woody or Dee: Arrested Dee, Woody didn't seem to know what was going on, while Dee was being very suspicious.
Prime Suspect: The Pimp, though the murders do fit Bluebeards MO.
Grendel: Ripped his arm off. Bigby is a fan of overkill and now Grendel will remember why Bigby is called "The Big Bad Wolf".
Faith: Gave her the money. Felt sorry for her.
Beauty and Beast: Told them both that I was staying out of it. Didn't know what the heck Beauty was up to, so how could I promise to cover for her?
Toad and Lawrence: Went to Toad's first. Sounded like serious stuff was going on, and I was a little concerned because I knew Toad had a kid. I was worried about the little guy.
Woody or Dee: I went after Woody. I think it was just tenaciousness at that point. I don't necessarily think that he did it, but I was trying to play the first time doing as close to what I would really do. Woody assaulted a girl who ended up dead. He assaulted me (the sheriff), and he did threaten to kill both of us. If I were in law enforcement and someone threatened a person who ended up dead later that night, I'd arrest them.
Prime Suspect: Didn't say anything. I honestly had no freakin' clue.
Grendel: I didn't rip off his arm. Not in the first playthrough. I kept thinking about Colin the pig's words and advice. I didn't want to just go and be the monster that everyone already thinks Bigby is. Plus, it's still an ongoing investigation. I may need to talk to these people again later or something...
In playthrough 2 I did everything different on purpose. Kept the money. Remained quiet with Beauty and told Beast that I saw her. Went to Lawrence, arrested Dee, ripped off Grendel's arm.
But the thing is that Bigby is not bound laws. He is the sheriff, but he can do thing his own way (more or less) .
Personally I went after Woody because he might be in danger, since the twins were after him. So now I didn't see him as a suspect but a witness.
He could provide good intel ...
But maybe I am wrong ... I hope I made the right choice
Then again, The twins seem to know something.
Personally I assume they are private detectives hired by the Pimp or someone else important. Most likely not by the killer since then they wouldn't investigate the case, right?
Faith: Didn't give the money to her. Thought Bigby might need it later. Sorry, Faith.
Beauty and Beast: Told Beauty I'd stay out of it, but ended up lying to Beast. Sorry, Beast.
Toad and Lawrence: Went to Toad first. Thought Lawrence was already dead, so I was more worried about Toad and the kid. Still worried about them too...
Woody or Dee: Went for Dee. Woody's sob story about the Red Riding Hood made me realize he's just some loser who doesn't really know what he's doing. Not the kind of guy to neatly place someone's severed head on some steps. Dee, however, could have some nice info about Faith and the murder.
Prime Suspect: Went with Bluebeard, even if I don't really think it's him. I actually suspect him to be Dee's boss.
Grendel: Didn't tear off his arm. The poor guy was crying already.
My choices as you see mostly go off of how I think Bigby would handle this if he is really committed to changing how people see him. To not be seen as a jerk or a monster to be feared.
Except Dee didn't actually have the proper id when you ask him. He could have been lying.
I gave Faith the money, she'd had a pretty rough night and seemed to be suggesting turning up with no money wasn't going to be good for her, thought I was gonna be saving her from trouble to an extent, thought wrong.
Told Beast, way I saw it, as sherrif Bigby shouldn't be lying to anyone about the whereabouts of a dudes wife to him when she's going out at night, and I kind of expected something to happen to her that could have been avoided if I hadn't lied
Went to see Lawrence, was kind of a tough one so I just made a quick call and went for the dude I'd seen was in definite trouble and just hoped for the best with Toad. Worked out well in the end. Although I do think the game doesn't do quite so good a job of emphasising the grave situation Lawrence is in in the moment you make the decision.
I didn't name a suspect, I didn't really have much inkling as to who it was and I didn't think the game had even introduced the killer yet so I just stayed quiet.
Arrested Dee, him and Dum seem far too suspicious to me, they seem to have some definite involvement in some way and even the dialogue as he enters the bar is suspicious. Also the Woodsman seemed genuinely quite reflective and down in the bar, and sounded pretty truthful in protesting his innocence.
I didn't rip off Grendel's arm. I mean, what's the point? Would have been pretty needlessly cruel when he'd been bested anyway, and was really just seemingly lashing out because of a system he didn't think cared about him (or Holly). I also didn't want to look like some brutal monster.
Faith: Gave her the money... Honestly, I was looking for some action more than it being the right thing to do... Looking back, I still would've done it, but more because It was the right thing to do.
Beauty and Beast: Told Beauty I wasn't getting involved. Ended up telling Beast the truth in case something ended up happening to her, i didn't want to be responsible.
Toad or Lawrence: Toad, Lawrence looked dead already and Toad sounded like he was in direct danger so I went to help him. Also seems like one of your few "friends."
Woody or Dee: Dee, Woody was a dick but I feel like he's not guilty and Dee could provide more answers than he could.
Prime Suspect: Bluebeard, because it was his M.O., although that may seem too obvious. I think it may actually be the pimp or someone who hasn't been introduced yet...
Grendel: Walked away, Bigby turned a new leaf and wasn't trying to create too many new enemies. Would've been even more bad ass if I still had the money to pay for the double whiskey...
Same exact choices as the OP
Faith: Gave money, cause why wouldn't you?
Beauty/beast: Promised Beauty I wouldn't tell, and I lied to Beast. I know Beauty must have a plan that will help me later, knowing her.
Toad or Lawrence: Toad thinking he was in trouble and Lawrence was dead. But then I went back and redid it to save Lawrence for obvious reasons. Don't care if it means Toad's a bit more bitter to me later.
Woodsman/Dee: Dee, because the Woodsman is obviously not guilty. For many reasons.
Grendel: Of course walked away, I ain't stooping down to the monster's level, I just don't see Bigby doing that. But I went back and got the arm off for the Book of Fables entry, naturally.
Prime Suspect: Bluebeard. Due to the comics, I know that bastard will be important in this. Who else could afford strong enough magic to keep the mirror and lips at bay? I wanted Crane as an option though, even though I don't think he actually murdered anyone.
Faith: Gave her money
Beauty and Beast : Lied to beast
Toad and Lawrence : Toad
Woody or Dee : Dee
Prime Suspect: Dum and Dee
Grendel: Left him, although I really wanted to tear it off because that guy was a douche. Bigsby already put the hurt on him and I figured it would come back to bite me later
Faith: Didn't give her money. Handouts never work.
Beauty and the Beast: Promised to lie, kept promise. I read the comics, so I know whatever's going will on they'll work things out in the end.
Toad and Lawrence: Toad. Mostly because Toad has a kid.
Woody or Dee: Dee. Woody clearly didn't kill Faith, and probably didn't know much about her than what she did for a living. Dee clearly knows something about this. Also, though Bigby didn't mention it, I caught at least one major lie in his explanation about what happened in Lawrence's apartment.
Prime Suspect: Named Dee. Probably someone who won't show up until Part 5.
Grendel: Walked away. Like Woody said, he had enough.
Faith: Choose to not give her money. Faith seemed like a though girl, I thought she'll be upset, if I give her money, maybe I hurt her pride or something.
B&B: I told Beauty I don't want to get involved, for I am a lone wolf. When Beast asked me, I told him i saw beauty. When he asked me when, I didn't respond. Just a smirk, and the close of the elevator door. That was a pretty badass moment.
Toad or Lawrence: I rushed to Toad. Regreted that decision.
Woody or Dee: Dee. Woody is a drunk asshole, but also an innocent asshole. Dee and his freakin' brother knocked me out. I wanted my revenge.
Grendel: Tore his arm off. Bleed, mofo, and NEVER, I repeat: NEVER(!!!) confront with a werewolf.
Faith: didn't give money
Beauty and Beast: told the truth
Go to Toad or Lawrence: Went to Lawrence
Woody or Dee: So wanted to get after Woody, but chose Dee
Prime Suspect: Lawrence (It's always the husband/wife)
Grendel: Ripped his arm off and paid for whiskey
For me when i first started the game its was trying to be the good guy..my decisions were trying to ask questions to faith, which came to no avail since she literally blew me off and walked away but i gave her the money i had seeing it was best. Second event was which area i should go next..i decided prince Lawrence seeing so many people say it sucks, i decided to see for myself. Far from what idiots said about this area i discovered his accident and heard a clue from him when i asked him some questions..of a name i can lead on.For beauty, i knew she wouldn't betray her husband by any means so yes i lied to protect her..plus i wanted to be a dick to beast with the silence option and it was my favorite scene of the episode lol. Lastly, i chose the tweedle because he not only beat me up but he knows something, i dint pick the huntsman because i don't think he knew anything and was just scared. However, why would dee search around his apartment for something? I don't know, but one things for sure justice will come for snow white, she was my fav in the comics.
I gave Faith money,I accepted to lie for Beauty and I went to Mr.Toad first because I thought that Lawrence was already dead and that there wouldn't be much we could do for him.I later went after Dee because Woody seemed sincere when he said he was innocent.As for Grendel,I didn't tear off his arm because I might need everyone's support at one moment in the story and I chose not to be violent or mean during my first playthrough.Everytime I play a game that lets us make different choices,I always choose the ones that I would choose in real life.My prime suspect is Faith's pimp because I don't really suspect any one we've met in this episode so far (except the ginger guy but his involvment still has to be confirmed).I think it would be too easy to introduce the killer in the first episode.We still have many fables to meet and many clues to find before we can put the puzzle together.And I don't think there is only one person involved.
everyone keeps talking about that ginger dude, for god sakes its no one interesting
Haha I didnt give faith the money because I thought she'd probably be offended because she would reason she could take care of herself
Well,we don't know yet.You may be true but I think that it's an interesting theory even if he turns out to be no one important.
Faith: I gave Faith the money since I didn't want her to get in trouble with her pimp, and possibly get an even worse beating than the one Woody gave her.
Beauty & Beast: I tried to stay out of it since I didn't want to get involved in whatever was going on between them.
Toad & Prince Lawrence: I went to help Toad first since he sounded like he was in the most trouble, and I figured Prince Lawrence had already been killed because of what you saw in the Magic Mirror.
Prime Suspect: The Tweedles are my prime suspects.
Woody or Dee: I arrested Dee. Him having blood all over his shirt when he entered the Trip Trap pretty much sealed the deal for me.
Grendel: I didn't rip his arm off. I understood why he is frustrated by how things are being run in Fabletown, so that's why I didn't do it even though I totally wanted to.
Funny we both got dissapointed, i gave her my money and i thought she'd give me a "happy ending".
I had three different save files for three different playthroughs. Normal one, nice Bigby and mean Bigby. The last two save-files don't really count because I made the choices knowing what their results would be just for maximum roleplaying effect.
So, the choices I made the first time around and will have to stick with in the main game were:
Faith: Gave her the money. Had no choice, this is a noir game and I just found the mysterious damsel in distress. WHAT ELSE COULD I DO?
Beauty and the Beast: Stayed out of it, told them both as much. No idea what is going on and I don't plan on lying to anyone.
Toad VS Prince Made the common mistake and chose Toad first, thought Lawrence was already dead while Toad had a chance of being saved.
Prime Suspect I said Pimp, I was thinking of just staying silent because there was still a lot of information missing but as of then Pimp was my main suspect, and he still is. I doubt he's actually the killer, though.
Grendel He's cool and has every right to be mad at the system. I spared him and hope he shows up again and we can be on friendlier term. I had a perverse joy when I played as the asshole and ripped his arm right of the socket, though.
Woodsman VS Dee Dee, neither of them are the murderers, but I wanted to know what the brothers were looking for and what information they gathered. Plus they punched me.
Faith: Gave her the money.
Beauty & Beast: I told Beauty that I wanted to stay out of it and I ended up lying to Beast.
Toad and Lawrence: I went to Toad first, I thought he was in some real trouble too.
Woody or Dee: Personally I don't think Woody is responsible for the murders, even if he is a dick. Whereas Dee is suspicious and I wanted to get him back for beating up Bigby before.
Prime Suspect: I suspected the Pimp largely because we have yet to meet him and he's still a possible contender at the moment.
Grendel: I ripped it off, haha. He was really beating the crap out of Bigby and I'm playing Bigby as a nice guy until you fuck him over, then he's someone to watch out for.