Suspect Rundown

Here I'll analyze each and every suspect and try to narrow the list down to the killer.

  1. The Woodsman: Though he certainly had the means and motive to kill Faith, why would he keep the body and put the head on display? And why would he kills Snow aswell?
  2. Bluebeard : Means but no motive, he typically kills his wives, and here neither Faith nor Snow were married to him.
  3. Lawrence: Does not have the means nor the motive, and he was sitting in his couch for an entire week so he couldn't have killed them
  4. The Pimp: Motive for first murder (Faith) but none for Snow.
  5. Tweedles : No motive, and they're trying to find the killer aswell.
  6. Headless Horseman: Possible, means but unknown motive and questionable existence.
  7. Redhead guy: Impossible considering he's probably just an extra model. Plus no motive for killing Faith.
  8. Grendel: Means and motive for killing Snow but no motive for Faith.

Currently we have no actual viable suspects aside from RHG and the Headless Horseman.

Comments

  • I'm going to feel a tightly bit slighted. If it ends up being Crane, the Mayor of the city. I said before the way their heads are cut off. It could be him. It was slammed as being a dumb idea. It does make sense logically, headless horseman...heads of victims..they always make it the not so obvious choice.

  • I don't think it's Crane, he gets fired due to a sexual harassment accusation by Snow later on. And Crane had no motive.

    fusedmass posted: »

    I'm going to feel a tightly bit slighted. If it ends up being Crane, the Mayor of the city. I said before the way their heads are cu

  • what about grendel. he's obviously upset with the system, but why would he kill faith? i really have no idea. :\

  • Perhaps to point out that the "real" investigation only begins when someone important like Snow is killed, while the little people like Faith only get the second hand treatment.

    staticfl posted: »

    what about grendel. he's obviously upset with the system, but why would he kill faith? i really have no idea.

  • It's likely considering his disgusting treatment of her.

    Though i'm not sure, it's told from Crane's PoV (When he's telling Cinderella about it.) so obviously he would deny it.

    ViralType posted: »

    He actually harassed her? Or was she just trying to get rid of him in the most non-violent way she could think of?

  • He actually harassed her? Or was she just trying to get rid of him in the most non-violent way she could think of?

  • Here's my opinion I don't think its possible for the Woodsman to have killed Snow since I do believe he was at the bar all night. Decapitation appears to be Blue beards MO so its possible. Again I don't think Lawrence could have killed Snow since if you visit him second he's killed himself. The Pimp is possible but its unlikely he'd drop the head on the Sheriff's door step unless he thought Faith was going to turn him in and even then it sounds like a dumb move. I doubt that Dee or Dum kill either of them I believe they've been hired to to find and acquire Faith's Donkey Skin cloak. On another topic in this forum someone puts forth the theory that these murders are directed at Crane if so the Horseman does have mean motive and opportunity and it is his MO. I don't think the Redhead is just a stock character another topic makes some good point that he may be "The Boy Who Cried Wolf" and for that reason he's the killer but in that same logic he may know who the killer is and hasn't told anyone because he's a famous liar and doesn't thin any one will believe him. Grendel's a honest to goodness monster so it is possible but for what reason and to what ends would be the question. As for me I don't believe there's enough evidence at the moment to make a decision.

  • Here's my opinion I don't think its possible for the Woodsman to have killed Snow since I do believe he was at the bar all night. Decapitation appears to be Blue beards MO so its possible. Again I don't think Lawrence could have killed Snow since if you visit him second he's killed himself. The Pimp is possible but its unlikely he'd drop the head on the Sheriff's door step unless he thought Faith was going to turn him in and even then it sounds like a dumb move. I doubt that Dee or Dum kill either of them I believe they've been hired to to find and acquire Faith's Donkey Skin cloak. On another topic in this forum someone puts forth the theory that these murders are directed at Crane if so the Horseman does have mean motive and opportunity and it is his MO. I don't think the Redhead is just a stock character another topic makes some good point that he may be "The Boy Who Cried Wolf" and for that reason he's the killer but in that same logic he may know who the killer is and hasn't told anyone because he's a famous liar and doesn't thin any one will believe him. Grendel's a honest to goodness monster so it is possible but for what reason and to what ends would be the question. As for me I don't believe there's enough evidence at the moment to make a decision.

  • It's possible the killer is someone we haven't met yet in the game.

  • I agree there's just not enough evidence to say for certain who did it.

    staticfl posted: »

    It's possible the killer is someone we haven't met yet in the game.

  • I suspect that we haven't met the real killer, and I'm willing to bet that we'll have at least two more major "fake out" type revelations in-story. Even if we do find the "real" killer by the end of Ep. 2, he/she is just a pawn, I'd wager.

Sign in to comment in this discussion.