User Avatar Image

Why Shel Knows Carver (Determinant)

posted by SaltLick305 BANNED on - Viewed by 1.7K users

When you are playing as Shel , If you decide to kill Stephanie Shel stays with her group , And when we see her in the Epilogue she talks about how staying in one place makes you an easy target , Then Russell talks about how vulnerable and dangerous Gils Pitstop was , Well I think if you do stay with the group there is a possibility Carver attacks them , and thats the reason why we found Roman dead in Season 2 , Its obvious they had a bad experience because they don't even mention Roman or the others when talking to Tavia she just states how dangerous every place is , Even the timeline makes this a very possible outcome to that situation , I guess we'll find out but one thig is for sure Shel and her group were attacked by someone , After what we've heard so far its safe to think Carver might have been involved

27 Comments
  • I definitely think some 400 days characters are involved with Carver's group anyways for sure and also I don't think it's been mentioned before but how do we know that Carver might not be the leader of the Tavia Settlement or at least have links with it somehow?

  • If Shel doesn't kill Stephanie then in the epilogue Shel or Becca does mention that they should go with Tavia because Roman might still be out there looking for them.

    It'll be interesting if for some players Shel and Becca know Carver or not based off of your decisions

    • User Avatar Image
      SaltLick305 BANNED

      Yeah that will make your decision matter in a most interesting way not just the going with Tavia or not thing , Besides if Vince does in fact appear in episode 4 , You could argue that the guy who kills Danny ( the rapist) could be Carver too , There's a lot of ways the story can go

      • Interesting! As I had Vince shot Danny it could be none of my 400 Days characters know who Carver is.

        • User Avatar Image
          SaltLick305 BANNED

          Well if my theories happen to be true in my playthrough Vince could know about Carver , But don't worry I know Telltale and whether they know Carver or not may end up just changing dialogue choices because they'll end up meeting him anyways

  • Carver could also be the "steve" guy who lead Russels group before.... There are quite a few possibilities to incorporate the characters

    • User Avatar Image
      SaltLick305 BANNED

      At first i thought Russell could have been related to the cabin survivors somehow but he said Steve said 7 was the magic number and when you count the cabin people it doesn't match because there is 8 unless one of the member (maybe Luke) joined the group after that , Maybe Carver was the Steve guy he was talking about and thats why they kicked him out of the group for being a psycho

  • Plot twist: The 400 days are in Carver's group and that's who Tavia was actually speaking to on the walkie-talkie.

    • User Avatar Image
      SaltLick305 BANNED

      Possible , what doesn't match is that the guy she is talking to states that they are building a good community and all that stuff , If they were bad i don't see why they wouldn't just say get these fuckers and we'll figure out what to do with them , He might not be that exact same guy but they might be related somehow

  • While this is well thought out, why would Shel head north, and then back south to be with her old group? I understand that they WERE at Gil's Pitstop before, but by the time Clem had seen Roman's dead body, which I presume was recent, Shel would already be with the other group, because this scene is at least 150 days late because Shel leaves with Tavia at the 400 days mark, IIRC. Replaying Season 1 now to refresh my memory.

This discussion has been closed.