A new "I thought you were dead" thought (Maybe)

edited January 2014 in The Walking Dead

There are so many discussions and arguments between people on the board about who people think Clem is talking about in the preview. I have to admit that I haven't read through the entirety of the board on the subject but I've read a lot and haven't seen this mentioned yet.

Maybe the person that Clem is talking about is both Kenny and Lilly. Maybe depending on who Lee sided with the most in season one will be the person that shows up in season 2. Then again, maybe whoever shows up will be who he sided with the least, causing conflict between that person and Clem.

I think this would be a cool idea and I think it's definitely doable considering it was done with Doug/Carly in season 1.

«1

Comments

  • There is one huge problem with this theory, its cannot be one or the another cause it makes no sense! What happent Kenny if Lilly showed up cause i was dick to her? It is pretty dumb if he or she is now with this douche gang cause Lee was dick to them and then is dick to Clem, and the one who Lee was nice just sucked through into the plothole and disappear from existence? Sry but no.

  • SaltLick305SaltLick305 Banned
    edited January 2014

    Everybody Im sorry to break to you but Telltale is NOT gonna let our decisions affect who is coming back next episode, They want us to play their story which I completely understand, Its time we wake up and realize our decisions will affect just dialogue choices and how Clem perceives a couple of events, Nothing else

  • Yeah I agree, however if they did it would create replay value

    SaltLick305 posted: »

    Everybody Im sorry to break to you but Telltale is NOT gonna let our decisions affect who is coming back next episode, They want us

  • You only missed Carlos's watch..

  • Sadly, I haven't made that one yet.

    Wheres Larry?

  • You should make a Larry one

    Sadly, I haven't made that one yet.

  • Of course we would all love but we know its not gonna happen, not only would it affect the story too much but it would be a nightmare for them to make the whole game adjust to people's choices,Unfortunately its not gonna happen

    Yeah I agree, however if they did it would create replay value

  • I just hope it's not Victor because if it is, I may have to buy some salt licks

    SaltLick305 posted: »

    Of course we would all love but we know its not gonna happen, not only would it affect the story too much but it would be a nightmare for them to make the whole game adjust to people's choices,Unfortunately its not gonna happen

  • Vince & Saltlick too :D

    You should make a Larry one

  • Well if my opinion is worth anything to you I'd go and buy a couple already because I do think its Him,While Kenny will appear Later in the episode

    I just hope it's not Victor because if it is, I may have to buy some salt licks

  • Knowing Telltale the ITYWD person will be revealed and then it cuts to the trailer for episode 3

    SaltLick305 posted: »

    Well if my opinion is worth anything to you I'd go and buy a couple already because I do think its Him,While Kenny will appear Later in the episode

  • I would like it to be determinant but really the only way that would work is if Kenny only comes back depending on if u saved Ben or not...

  • SaltLick305SaltLick305 Banned
    edited January 2014

    Nah They are not that stupid, The person is gonna be revealed next episode and its gonna be Victor, So when everyone is flipping because it wasn't Kenny is when we'll come across the moustache Man

    Knowing Telltale the ITYWD person will be revealed and then it cuts to the trailer for episode 3

  • I doubt it's Victor. It's impossible for a man in his condition to get up, run from walkers and be healed in a matter of moments

    SaltLick305 posted: »

    Nah They are not that stupid, The person is gonna be revealed next episode and its gonna be Victor, So when everyone is flipping because it wasn't Kenny is when we'll come across the moustache Man

  • He lives regardless

    I would like it to be determinant but really the only way that would work is if Kenny only comes back depending on if u saved Ben or not...

  • Yeah, I should make those XD

    GOUSTTTT posted: »

    Vince & Saltlick too

  • I don't think its Lilly manly because Clementine said "I thought you where dead". Clementine has no reason to think Lilly is dead because the last time she saw her she was alive and well either left on the side of the road or runs off in the RV. So i think it could be Kenny or Victor (The guy you can give water to at the end of the episode)

  • SaltLick305SaltLick305 Banned
    edited January 2014

    We don't know how many days passed since we saw him in the river to the moment when we see this mystery person, Besides my prediction isn't that he just ran away, He stayed there basically playing dead as you saw so the walker didn't attack him, Some other group came across that mess at the river like we did and helped him when they saw he was alive, Maybe they were part of his group since the 2 guys in the preview look like bandits, He was in a tough situation no doubt but thats what makes a person presumed dead for real, The only 2 people that make sense are Victor and Kenny because Clementine doesn't think either Christa or Lily died

    I doubt it's Victor. It's impossible for a man in his condition to get up, run from walkers and be healed in a matter of moments

  • I agree for the most part.
    However it can't be longer then a few days. Remember, the majority saved Pete. The only people who make sense are Kenny and Victor.

    SaltLick305 posted: »

    We don't know how many days passed since we saw him in the river to the moment when we see this mystery person, Besides my predictio

  • This is my prediction, Ep 2 starts where we left off and Pete cuts off his leg and passes out, The game skips to maybe a week later and it is revealed that Pete didn't survive tha amputation, Then that man comes to the house and gives Clementine some kind of message from Carver that causes the group to leave the house , I think He sent that guy to let Rebecca know he is coming for his baby or slmething along those lines

    I agree for the most part. However it can't be longer then a few days. Remember, the majority saved Pete. The only people who make sense are Kenny and Victor.

  • edited January 2014

    Alt text

  • I think Troy is going to join you. Think about it, in a leaked image of him, it seems as though he is in the same place as Clem and the others. Plus, in the Amid the Ruins slide one of the silhouettes looks like him. He may be a good guy, he warned Clem right? Also, why wouldn't Pete survive? I'm sure the group has enough medical equipment.

    SaltLick305 posted: »

    This is my prediction, Ep 2 starts where we left off and Pete cuts off his leg and passes out, The game skips to maybe a week later

  • You have a point, so lets change that part of my theory, instead of Carver telling him to come see us he wants to attack the group by surprise and take Rebecca and the baby, But Troy knowing he was gonna hurt a pregnant woman refused to be part of the plan and came to warn the group which causes them to leave, Later he ends up joining us

    I think Troy is going to join you. Think about it, in a leaked image of him, it seems as though he is in the same place as Clem and

  • I think he is the father of Rebecca's baby. He overhears Carver saying he wants to attack them. Knowing his baby could die, he warns Clem & joins them. After Alvin and Rebecca die he takes care of his baby.

    SaltLick305 posted: »

    You have a point, so lets change that part of my theory, instead of Carver telling him to come see us he wants to attack the group b

  • SaltLick305SaltLick305 Banned
    edited January 2014

    Until I meet Him Im not gonna put my money on him being the father, For now im sticking with Carver

    I think he is the father of Rebecca's baby. He overhears Carver saying he wants to attack them. Knowing his baby could die, he warns Clem & joins them. After Alvin and Rebecca die he takes care of his baby.

  • I doubt Carver would kill a baby, let alone his own.

    SaltLick305 posted: »

    Until I meet Him Im not gonna put my money on him being the father, For now im sticking with Carver

  • SaltLick305SaltLick305 Banned
    edited January 2014

    I didn't say he was gonna kill him, I said he wanted to take the baby and since the group for some reason that we still don't know thinks he is a complete Psychopath and mass murderer decide to leave, I dont think hes that sick yet to kill his own baby

    I doubt Carver would kill a baby, let alone his own.

  • Carver, you are NOT the father

    SaltLick305 posted: »

    I didn't say he was gonna kill him, I said he wanted to take the baby and since the group for some reason that we still don't know t

  • edited January 2014

    Make one for Lee :D

    Yeah, I should make those XD

  • ...Lee an't coming back bro BUT Lee's arm on the other hand, I just have a feeling we will see it again.

    Alt text

    Make one for Lee

  • Lee's arm confirmed for Season 2

    GOUSTTTT posted: »

    ...Lee an't coming back bro BUT Lee's arm on the other hand, I just have a feeling we will see it again.

  • GOUSTTTTGOUSTTTT Banned
    edited January 2014

    I tried to make them myself on Imgflip but i can't figure it out, Could you help me, Pretty Please :)

    Alt text

    Yeah, I should make those XD

  • edited January 2014

    How does one post a picture

    GOUSTTTT posted: »

    I tried to make them myself on Imgflip but i can't figure it out, Could you help me, Pretty Please

  • Ask Viva-La-Lee, I an't good at explaining stuff.

    How does one post a picture

  • GOUSTTTT posted: »

    Ask Viva-La-Lee, I an't good at explaining stuff.

  • Make a gif for Lees arm :D

    Lee's arm confirmed for Season 2

  • Now we need to just make it move like this :D

    Alt text

    http://l.wigflip.com/a/VPKaLj8s/roflbot.jpg

This discussion has been closed.