This discussion may contain spoilers!
Since we're all speculating about who the killer is, I thought it might be useful to have a thread for keeping track of what we know for sure about the killer so far. No theories, just the facts.
- Both victims have been women who worked at the Pudding & Pie.
- All of the women who work at the Pudding & Pie where a ribbon around their necks. Faith's head was found with this ribbon in her mouth, but Lily's was not.
- All of the women who work at the Pudding & Pie use the phrase, "These lips are sealed," when asked for information about their employer.
- The killer has decapitated both of his victims and left their heads on the steps of the Woodlands.
- The murder weapon is a blade, possibly enchanted.
- The last known people to see the first victim were Bigby and Woody at Woody's apartment building. She intended to see Bigby at the Woodlands before she was killed.
- The $58.00 that Bigby gives Faith is later found in Georgie's safe at the Pudding & Pie.
- Woody was expecting Lily the night of Faith's murder. A note was found at the Pudding & Pie indicating that Faith was covering for Lily.
- The last known person to see the second victim was Ichabod Crane. He was a client engaging in a role-playing fantasy involving Snow White's poisoning from the fairy tales.
- Lily's sister Holly reported that she was missing prior to Faith's murder.
- Lily was killed in Room 207 of the Open Arms Hotel, the same room where she met with Crane. That room is being rented out long-term. The master key to hotel rooms did not work on the door to this room.
- A piece of blue fabric, possibly from the killer's pants, was found at the first crime scene.
- An unidentified person seen dumping Lily's body in the river was heard saying, "Stop laughing at me."
- Huff n Puff brand cigarettes, possibly smoked by the killer, were found in the ashtray in the room where Lily was killed.
What else should we add to the list?
2/7 - Added the information about the victims wearing ribbons, the phrase "these lips are sealed," and Lily being killed in Room 207. Added information about Faith covering for Lily the night of Faith's murder. Added information about the money Bigby gave Faith being in Georgie's safe.