I made a post about this in the forum and was told I could mention it here and maybe receive some help.
I played the Wolf Among Us today and found that my two save files are the same thing. I play on the PS3 and they are in slots 1 and 4. One playthrough I prevented Lawrence's death and arrested the Woodsman and was generally nice. The other, I was mean, Lawrence died and I arrested Dee.
Now both files are of the latter, mean playthrough. So it seems somehow my original first file is gone or somehow overwritten by the other one. This really upsets me and other posters have mentioned that the PC is the best, least glitchy version of this game. Is there a way I can play it on the PC and not have to repay given whatever happened set me back many hours. I am very dissatisfied and it makes me want to stop playing entirely if we have to wait so many months for episodes that come out very messy on my platform, not to mention losing an entire playthrough.
Point is, somehow my file was lost and I would like to play on the PC to avoid the game's issues in the future. If nothing can be helped, I'll probably going to stop playing entirely and just watch playthroughs or I'll wait until all the episodes are released so this can't happen if I play them all at one time.