I thought you were DEAD

Here Are the suspects
-Lily
-kenny
-christa
-Omid
-the weird man(antagonist) season 1
-lee
What do you think post below

«1

Comments

  • Well considering there's about 100050303493 threads on this.

    Oh well,

    KENNYYYYYYY

  • speaking for 99,9% of twd players, kenny

  • edited February 2014

    Omid and that weird guy are definitely dead. You think they didn't check if Omid was really dead before leaving him? They would of shot him in the head before leaving too. If it was Lee she wouldn't say "I thought you were dead" in that tone, she'd freak out and run to hug him. Neither of these are options, they don't make any sense to me.

    It's either Lilly, Kenny, or Christa. If it's anyone else, there's going to be a lot of angry people. The episode is taking so long to release, and hyping us up for something very small like a minor character would piss a lot of people off. I don't think it will be Christa, that would be too obvious and I feel that's what they thought people would assume. Not many fans of her either. I personally am hoping for Kenny. He is the only character left that I have a emotional connection too (other than Clem obviously!). He'd make a good dad for Clem, and help patch the giant gaping hole of Lee's death.

    It's really NEEDS to be Kenny for multiple reasons.

  • edited February 2014

    IS KENNY 100%

  • edited February 2014

    I know right! Kenny, in my opinion is one of the ONLY ways to make Season 1 choices matter truly. He was there from pretty much the start to the end of Lee's story.

    You could say Lily was too, but she wasn't there for the second half of Episode 3 to the end.

    So in my opinion, I agree with you, IT NEEDS TO BE KENNY.

  • KENNY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • Would prefer Lilly a little bit as Kenny got his redemption so its only fair Lilly gets a shot too.

    That said Anyone other than Kenny or Lilly or Christa would be kind of a let down, Clem shouldn't be that shocked about anyone else

  • Im Tired of saying this but between all those people I go with....

    TeamMoustache

  • Laugh if was ben probably not possible could just imagine internet rage getting all excited and seeing ben he ruins everything

  • Considering that Kenny is my profile picture, I'm guessing that it's pretty obvious who I want it to be.

  • There is no way Lee is alive, but there is another thread talking about hallucinations. I think it would be really cool if Clementine hallucinated Lee in front of everyone at the camps. She would not be jumping for joy though, how would you feel if somebody who died 16 months ago randomly appeared in a bandit camp, somebody you killed/put out of their misery?

  • I know this might sound familiar, but I´m all for Kenny. Even though the writers from TT would have to come up with a pretty good explanation on how he survived at the end on season one.

  • Well it's definitely not Lee. As much as I want it to be it's not. Some people say that maybe someone found Lee and cured him. The likelyhood of that happening is very low. And for something big like that it'd need to fit for all the players. Like me. I shot Lee. No coming back from that. So no I don't believe it's Lee. Kenny and Christa make sense but she looked frightened. That leaves Lily making the most sense. So my vote goes to Lily. I feel like it will be someone else though. Only because it's to predictable. Watch it be someone completely different.

  • This speak's for itself.

    Alt text

  • edited February 2014

    It might be Kenny or Lilly and i hope it is. But it's most likely Christa TBH though i would be kinda disappointed if it was plus her reaction seemed too - shocked- if it was christa i think she'd be a little less shocked and more relieved too see that she managed too get away........if that makes sense.

  • edited February 2014

    One word moustache.Alt text

  • I don't think there is any way at all it will be any character we have "seen" die – e.g. Omid. It would be pretty cheap storytelling. In TWD death is a serious thing, this isn't Lost! There is absolutely no way it's Lee, it would render the entire last episode of season 1 meaningless.

    Kenny's death trying to save Ben felt like it was finishing out his character arc. He's got nothing left to live for now his family is gone. The boat plan was the last thread he was hanging on to and now that's screwed. He feels like he owes Ben. Also it would be a tough sell to convince us he could have survived that situation. I'd honestly be very surprised if it was him.

    My money's on Christa but Lilly is also a possibility and would be dramatically interesting.

    Another possibility is Molly. Although I don't know all the outcomes for her in season 1 based on my game she could still be alive.

    I can't help but think Clem's "I thought you were dead" will be the cliffhanger at the end of episode 2 and we won't see who she's actually talking about until episode 3!

  • Do not even say things like that.

  • It's kenny for sure, in the game files it says kenny202 and a house divided.

  • if you look at the episode 4 in the game you'll see shadow figures and Clementine in the middle , Kenny is Among them

  • Clem has no reason to suspect Lilly to be deceased, and she firmly believes Christa is alive. It's Kenny, or it's someone we don't know yet/is definitely alive currently, and will 'die' partway through the episode.

  • I agree with you for the most part, but knowing TellTale, the scenes from the trailers aren't normally in the actual game, so the approach is probably different.

  • Lilly just was abandoned, not supposed dead by Clem. Lee is obviously dead, there's no way he survived, I mean if he did (no that I wouldn't be happy) it's not a very, um, credible story. It's hard but I think we have to accept it. Then Omid, he's dead for sure, I mean, I don't really believe Christa wouldn't have checked his vital signs, you know? Mm the stranger, well he's also dead for sure. I mean, one of the options were to choke him and then NOT to shoot him, but I don't really think they would give you that choice, I mean, the guy's obviously dead. So only Kenny is left, unless Clem DID think Lilly was dead, but she didn't see her dying, just abandoned. That being said, Kenny coming back would be awesome, plus in all of HIS endings he has a mysterious disappearance, so... I think it was kinda planned to make it be that way for season 2

  • Why would Clem think she was dead?

  • I don't know. There are so many people saying it's Kenny, I'm thinking that might be exactly why it won't be Kenny. Think about it. Telltale probably knows how many people there are on the forums with theories about how Kenny somehow survived Episode 5. So they probably know that everyone is going to guess it's Kenny as soon as they hear Clementine say, "I thought you were dead." And they wouldn't throw out that big of a spoiler in the preview. Unless it's just a red herring, and they want everyone to think it's Kenny to direct attention away from the character they're really bringing back.

    My bet would be on either Lilly or Christa. Maybe Molly (I hope).

  • I'll repeat; Clem doesn't think any of them are dead. Doesn't make sense.

  • I agree with you, but the thing is that none of those characters are believed dead, Lilly was abandoned, Christa= ???? And Molly just left. You see? Plus someone in this thread said that there is a game file called Kenny202 or sth. But, maybe you're right. Maybe it's far too obvious

  • Silly. It's obviously Juice Box.

  • Regardless of her true status, Christa is believed to be alive by Clem at the current point in the game.

  • How do you know? Lilly was left alone on a walker-infested road with no supplies. Christa was last seen being attacked by a group of bandits who had her outnumbered. I know if I were Clementine, I would definitely think that Lilly is dead. And I'd be having some serious doubts about Christa.

    Does she know for sure that they're dead? No, of course not. But she's also a thinking, feeling human being, not a computer, and she has plenty of reason to suspect that they might be dead. That's why she says, "I thought you were dead," not, "I knew you were dead."

  • I never said that she KNEW any of them were dead, making that point irrelevant. Up until all this nonsense with the three Lillys, Game Lilly==Comic Lilly, and Comic Lilly was very much alive. Even without that, she wasn't SURROUNDED by zombies, there were just a good few of them wandering out of woodwork. And even then, that's determinant, so what if in somebody else's game, Lilly came along and took the RV? She's not dead, and Clem has no reason to think so.

    Dialogue in S2E1 implies that Clem believes Christa to be very much alive, as she is searching for her and for information on her when she finds Victor. It's unlikely that she's dead regardless, and it would be WAY too obvious if it was her. I'd be disappointed in Telltale if it was her.

  • Omids VA straight up said that Omid is in fact dead via youtube, I would say it's not accurate but I know for a fact this guy is the real deal. I've asked him about Omid a few times before, and wether or not he's gotten any word from Telltale on if he's coming back, and he always said "maybe"(Pretty freaking cool that the guy goes around responding to people though). However, this is the first time he's said "no" so I'm just going to assume it's for real.

  • It's illogical to think it's Omid anyway. Christa would have made SURE he was gone, and that he didn't turn. No way is he coming back.

  • edited February 2014

    In my S1 Molly got attacked by the zombies cause I can't shoot for $h*t. I agree we never actually saw Kenny die so definitely could be him.

  • I hope its Kenny. I actually used to be a Kenny hater, but now I'm in with the moustache club. I should grow one like his.

  • Up until all this nonsense with the three Lillys, Game Lilly==Comic Lilly, and Comic Lilly was very much alive.

    Robert Kirkman has confirmed that the Lilly in the comics is a different Lilly than the one in the game. Meaning that Lee's Lilly could very well be dead.

    Even without that, she wasn't SURROUNDED by zombies, there were just a good few of them wandering out of woodwork. And even then, that's determinant, so what if in somebody else's game, Lilly came along and took the RV? She's not dead, and Clem has no reason to think so.

    Why does it matter whether or not she was "surrounded" by zombies a year and a half ago? No matter what you choose, Lilly still ends up on the road alone with few if any supplies. And this is a world where that is practically a death sentence. And Clementine has been around long enough to know that. Again, could Lilly have survived? Sure. It's possible. But Clem has every reason to think that she might be dead.

    Dialogue in S2E1 implies that Clem believes Christa to be very much alive, as she is searching for her and for information on her when she finds Victor.

    Now that actually does depend on what the player chose. And we don't know how much time passes in Episode 2 before Clementine's "I thought you were dead" line. It's entirely possible that Clem could have given up hope of finding Christa alive by that point in the game. Especially given the situation she was in when we last saw her.

    I'd be disappointed in Telltale if it was her.

    Well, I'll be disappointed in Telltale if it turns out to be Kenny. I guess there's just no pleasing everyone.

Sign in to comment in this discussion.