Who do you think would win in hand to hand combat...

SpareClem2014SpareClem2014 Banned
edited February 2014 in The Walking Dead

In Hand to hand combat, Random black chick(Michelle) that shot Omid or Clementine after the flash forward in the story? Go!

Place your bets now ladies and gentlemen.

(Before you deny her being alive remember she was only shot in what looked like the gut but it could of been a thigh shot or in a non vital area. We also cant account for any signs of life after fade to black/flash forward.)



  • Random black chick got shot dead, so the fights over!

  • 'Random Black Chick' was named Michelle.

    And depends on if you mean Clementine back then, or Clementine after the time jump.

  • Clem after the flash forward.

  • Not that she will be coming back like your post implies, but if she were alive I would put my money on Clem. Even though we really don't know anything about the other girl, hell for all we know she could have been training to be a pro boxer before the ZA.

  • Trying to answer this but image of michelle beating up my little clem for no reason is hard to imagine physically not fair fight so Michelle going win easy money unless weapons are involved

  • SpareClem2014SpareClem2014 Banned
    edited February 2014

    Its been a while since their last confrontation but where she was shot could give Clem an advantage if she has not fully healed. It takes a while for a gun injury to heal if shot in the abdomen area. My uncle was shot there while hunting at point blank and after he healed up a few months he got punched in that area and it ruptured his intestine.

  • edited February 2014

    That evens it out clem very intelligent so if she used tactics just aiming for that spot has chance also michelle movement wont be good with bullet wound and clem fast to maybe clem easy win but two rounds since come back as zombie be good mini game at menu within game with all characters like street fighter

    Zombie clem v michelle = michelle win

    Zombie michelle v Clem = Michelle win

    But Kenny V Lee be best fight or Doug V Ben

  • Haha street fighter TWD style minigame! I want it!

  • SpareClem2014SpareClem2014 Banned
    edited February 2014

    Or a fight with pregnant Rebecca. How do you fight a pregnant lady? Do you just let her beat you up? lol

  • Bonus round clean dishes, wipe the floor and clean bedrooms as fast you can with rebecca

  • After the fast forward, I'd put my money on Clem. Especially after what she did to the zombie in the shed.

  • Well considering the "Random Black Chick" is dead I don't see the chances of this happening but to answer your question I take Clem, She was able to outlast a strong man used to make these kind of attacks so Its Impossible for me to see a scared teenager who just wanted to play the tough bitch do what he couldn't

  • edited February 2014

    Hmm... It depends.

    If Clem has a chance to try and use the environment to her advantage, then she'd win. If running and dodging won't really help Clem, then I'd have to say that she probably isn't stronger than Michelle.

    Then again, Clem is smarter as well.

    So basically, if there's a situation where Clem can outsmart Michelle, or use the environment against her, then Clementine would be the clear winner.

  • Jesus are you fuckin' kidding me?!?

  • You are on my last fucking nerve !

  • You seem to know a lot about her from a 45 second scene.

    She may look bigger, bigger doesn't mean stronger.

    She may seem less smart, but we didn't have much of a conversation did we?

    She may not be able to use the environment as wel as Clem, but where did you get that idea?

  • I don't know any more lines he says. So I'll sub my own!


  • This one.... Lyin' Bitch !

  • Poor Christa! Such hurtful words. And an even more hurtful spear!

  • I don't mean to be a dick but Huh the last word of that phrase does kind of summarize how she was behaving towards Clem at that moment, Though you could say She had her reasons

  • edited February 2014

    Indeed, very cold. I can't blame her that much though, lets be honest Clem had a pretty large role in Omid's death, and perhaps indirectly the babies death because of that. It would be hard to look at the girl who could be considered the causual (is that a word?) killer of your family every day for 16 months.

    EDIT: The word I was trying to make already exists and doesn't mean what I wanted it to. Consider it like being the cause of - the insitigator of - the reason that - etc. I'm sure you can identify the point I was trying to make.

  • Finally I come across someone who isn't Completely blind, We all love Clem but we have to admit she is somewhat to blame for his death, And Lee's too, Hell she says so herself... " Sometimes people die because of me"

  • I do believe she is partly to blame, but I also believe she is being a bit hard on herself. She is after all 9 or younger when those two deaths happen, and Omid's can also be atributed to a lot of shitty luck (like her bottle rolls under exactly when she walks in... fuucckkk) Lee's was even moreso her fault than Omid's was imo, but her parents were on the line..... that's a seriously powerful temptation when you are 9 and with strangers, let alone when the world has fallen apart.

    But to deny she had anything to do with their deaths is ridiculous.

  • edited February 2014

    I assumed Clem is smarter because really, she is one of the smartest characters. I assumed Clem can use the environment to her advantage better because that is mainly what she does in fights, rather than Lee, who used smarts and brute strength. Also, I just figured than an adult would be stronger than an 11 year old because.... She's an 11 year old.

  • I couldn't agree more with what you just said on top, She is just a kid and its the zombie apocalypse, Shit happens , Im pretty sure those two guys have a smile on their face right know because they died protecting her , It would be selfish for someone to put all that on her or dislike her for that but those who deny she is resposible in a way look foolish

  • Why would you consider 'her' (the name escapes me, I apologize) an adult? She looked mid teens to me.

    She isn't much bigger than Clem, chances are she is a master of environmental manipulation also :p

    ....I'll give you the smart one, Clem is a sharp nail in a pile of rocks.

  • Couldn't have said it better myself.

  • It will be weird when someone comes across this conversation, For a moment it looks like we are talking to ourselves lol

  • edited February 2014

    She's more of an adult than Clementine anyway.

    And I think that using the environment to your advantage and being smart tie into each other, at least a little. And I'd just assume that Michelle probably is more comfortable with firearms("I'll pop you!").

  • I haven't been talking to myself?

    Puts the mirror down


  • What a sudden realization Huh ?

  • True, but Sarah is older than my estimate of how old 'whats-her-name' is, and I would never say Sarah is stronger than Clem.

    Maybe a little, but I don't think resourcefulness stems directly from intelligence. Lets take army personel for example, while they are very good at using their surroundings during combat I wouldn't consider most of them 'smart'... after all they joined the army for a reason (just a joke don't get tempermental). Now that isn't saying all army soldiers are dumb, my cousin scored 3 points shy of the top score on the ASVAB and I didn't do to shabby myself, but on average the IQ of soldiers is lower than... most other jobs.

    It's easy to talk big when your the only one holding a gun. She didn't seem very comfortable with the gun when Omid walked in...

  • edited February 2014

    In the end Telltale won because the first thing I thought of when she was going to pick up the bottle was "Clem, pick that gun up. Never leave it unattended. Come on. Pick it up. Oh great. I can't. Why Telltale?!"

  • Zombie Michelle vs Clem = Clem win. Clem. With the Hammer. In the Shed.
    Zombie Clem v Michelle = Never gonna happen cause Clem's not gonna be a zombie, don't say stuff like that!

  • I'm going to blame the person who actually took Clem's gun, wouldnt give it back, and shot Omid with Omid's death, rather than Clem.

    By the logic, you could blame Christa and Omid for Clem's death otherwise, since they shouldnt have left Clem be alone in the bathroom, or at least had one of them outside to keep watch.

  • Clem beat Winston, who's an adult. By using the environment.

    She also beat an adult zombie, in an enclosed space, who took her by surprise :) Clem's one tough cookie.

Sign in to comment in this discussion.