This discussion may contain spoilers!
...and no, it isn't a fear of gelato.
I am referring to the suspect that Toad Jr. identified as tossing Lily's body into the river. He claimed the suspect was telling someone to stop laughing at them...though no one else was apparently present.
For those who do not know, gelatophobia is a fear of being laughed at by others, and this suspect clearly has an unstable fixation with being ridiculed. This begs the question: Which Fable is known for having an aversion to laughter?