Who do you think the killer is?

edited February 2014 in The Wolf Among Us

I think the killer is Snow White. Out of everyone in Bigby's investigation so far, she is the only one with a crystal clear motive. What do you guys and gals think?

Comments

  • edited February 2014

    Beauty seeing nothing in the hotel reception and not hearing the murder plus in room when she agrees with your verdict on what happened and says good work suspicious. She sneaks out of her house like a spie just hide a job from beast and someone ends up dead lies!!! Beast shows up just as you are about to enter the room and beauty is reluctant to give you the key to that room but then again games like this make me very paranoid so not sure

  • The Headless Horseman :)

    MakesSense

  • I think that Snow wants to get rid of Ichabod Crane because she's sick of being a "maid" all the time. I also think that the taxi-driver is her accomplice because he always seems to show up mostly when Bigby and Snow are together.

  • The orange haired man who seemed to be everywhere in Episode 1.

  • And nowhere to be seen in Episode 2 , Seems like Telltale got rid of him as soon as people started to talk about him and jumped to the conclusion he was the killer

    The orange haired man who seemed to be everywhere in Episode 1.

  • edited February 2014

    My sibling doesn't trust Beast or Beauty and think they are both in it together, lol. They also said they suspect Jack Horner because in his bio it says he thinks he is the most important fable but in reality everyone thinks of him as a joke. Well that would be quite unsuspecting except in that case it was already mentioned now. Mentioned something about North Wind too, Bigby's father. But I don't know about any of those guesses, lol. I actually hope it's an entirely new person that has not even been introduced yet working behind the scenes but I don't know who the killer is yet.

    I just know Crane is hiding something and he may or may not be the killer and may have hired someone else instead.

  • Maybe, but he might show up again in future episodes.

    SaltLick305 posted: »

    And nowhere to be seen in Episode 2 , Seems like Telltale got rid of him as soon as people started to talk about him and jumped to the conclusion he was the killer

  • I still think that we didn't see the killer yet, we're only at episode 2.I think that several people are involved and they use glamour so that no one notices them.For now I can't wait to learn more about the crooked man and the two brothers.

  • Definetly the killer isn't snow.Sorry to break your theory,but the killer is not snow.My suspects are:Crane/The boy who cried wolf/The Croocked man

  • I think Crane used the same spell on Beauty as he did on the police precinct at the beginning of the episode when he got Bigby out. That is why she doesn't remember seeing anything.

    Markd4547 posted: »

    Beauty seeing nothing in the hotel reception and not hearing the murder plus in room when she agrees with your verdict on what happe

  • Wow wow wow do you read the comics because if you did you would know that Snow is the best person in Fabletown besides Bigby unless you are joking then im sorry.

    sirxchrish posted: »

    I think that Snow wants to get rid of Ichabod Crane because she's sick of being a "maid" all the time. I also think that the taxi-driver is her accomplice because he always seems to show up mostly when Bigby and Snow are together.

  • I haven't heard anybody mention Bluebeard as the killer. He seems like a crooked bastard and he has that knife in the interrogation scene that looks like it could take someone's head off.

  • The year the game takes place in is the year Crane is fired. Think about this... If Telltale wants us to read the comics they will make you read the comics for the ending. Makes sense to me. And who would be the killer then? Crane. Is there a lot of evidence so far? No. Was evidence gathered before Crane's strange execution? yes. There is a huge hint that Crane will be fired. When looking at the second page of Snow White's story, Empire. Doesn't that ring a bell to people who read the comics?

  • I've never read the comic before.

    papai46 posted: »

    Wow wow wow do you read the comics because if you did you would know that Snow is the best person in Fabletown besides Bigby unless you are joking then im sorry.

  • I have not read the comic before, have you? If so, does it say why Crane was fired?

    LukaszB posted: »

    The year the game takes place in is the year Crane is fired. Think about this... If Telltale wants us to read the comics they will m

  • edited February 2014

    He was fired because he attempted to kiss Snow, that's all that is mentioned. And another reason the killer is not Snow is because she always tells Bigby the truth, also she ends up being Bigby's wife.

    sirxchrish posted: »

    I have not read the comic before, have you? If so, does it say why Crane was fired?

  • YO MAMA!Ok,sorry,just kidding.

  • edited February 2014

    I know there is a downvoter troll. So I'm gonna say this once.STOP THE BULLSHIT!

  • Lol, I think you might be right. Don't feed it.

    LukaszB posted: »

    I know there is a downvoter troll. So I'm gonna say this once.STOP THE BULLSHIT!

  • I'm playing this game purely from observation of someone else,playing. Never heard of the comics or other games linked to it. That being said, after playing episodes one and two, the killer is the queen. Tweedle dee and dums "boss". I think she may be in this game. Why the heck are they snooping,around? Plus both women murdered had their heads cut off. Remember Alice in Wonderland, the queens favorite phrase "off with her head!"

  • I think its a Mundy who learn about the fables existance

  • Personally, I think a couple of fables mentioned are deemed liable suspects, while others are not. Here is a quick overview of every character. Any opinion with # at end is definite.

    Bigby: He was asleep at the death of Faith, and arresting Dee/The Axeman (whichever you chose to arrest) at the death of Snow aka Holly's sister, Lily. #INNOCENT

    Snow: Little bit of speculation at this point, not yet sure if she is the murderer, as she is separated from Bigby at every crime scene and happened to be the one to find the head. Nevertheless, I believe she is 100% innocent

    The Boy Who Cried Wolf: Here is an interesting character, with definite suspicion surrounding the case as he appears in many scenes in Episode 1. He is shown at the beginning, driving the Taxi, generally appearing in multiple scenes and is even knocked down during the chase sequence with Dee. This, as a result, is the first #SUSPECT

    Crane: Definitely something fishy going on with Crane. However I believe he is innocent. He fantasizes about sexual relations with Snow, and as a result has turned Lily into Snow. Maybe he is just running in fright of the consequences. However, this does not explain how all the blood got on the bed. I believe someone else snuck into the room and murdered her after Crane had left, which I will cover below. Thus, crane is a potential suspect.

    The Woodsman: We first met the Woodsman beating Faith in Episode One. He is seen as aggressive and is the first character we are introduced to being the suspect in the series. Faith's death would leave him as the prime suspect, with motive, and the blessed axe for the head dismemberment. There is also the option to arrest him or Dee at the end of Episode 1, and regardless of which you arrest (Axeman or Dee) Lily dies anyway. Also it would be far too cliché for the murderer to be framed and suspected by Bigby in the opening episode. #INNOCENT

    Dum, Dee + BOSS: 100% Innocent, I can guarantee that while there is suspicion around these guys, again it would be far to cliché and easy to name these guys as the murderers. I believe the boss also has the same motive as Bigby, to find the Killer. So I believe these 3 are innocent.

    Blackbeard: Has the old storytale of being a violent killer, yet as he too was introduced in EP1 and would be too cliché, I believe he is innocent

    Beauty and the Beast: Now HERE is an interesting case. There isn't a lot of background on Beast yet, so I'm completely unsure about him. However, his wife Beauty, Has A LOT to answer for, Firstly, we now know where she was headed off to in EP1, to the 'Working Girl' building, working there as a receptionist/admin. The Lily Murder (coming back to the Dee/Dum case) is very speculate around her. She has a key to the room, and Bigby doesn't recognise any forced way of entry into the room, meaning whoever was in there had access to the key. This makes her the perfect candidate. Another pointer here, not saying it is her, But someone is in the room with Crane, which funnily enough noone has seemed to pick up on. It's a photograph with Crane putting BOTH of his hands on Lily's body, meaning he didn't take a 'selfie'. Someone was actively taking pictures in the room, meaning a second person was in there unless the camera was on a timer, but now I'm getting too technical. However, getting back to Beauty, she is mentioned by Dee and therefore suspected, and as a result, cures part of her innocence, but at this stage, I believe she is some way tied with this, and so is titled a #SUSPECT

    The Crooked Man: I see a lot of people talking about him, and have no idea who he is, unless it is AKA the Boy Who Cried Wolf, so I cannot speculate on his case or already have.

    Gren: Vicious individual, but hates Snow and cares a lot for Holly, so if he wanted to kill Snow, he wouldn't kill a fake snow white which ironicly enough ended up being holly's sister...OR WOULD HE? Apart from this, we know nothing about this character. So until proven guilty, innocent for now.

    Narissa AKA The Little Mermaid: We were just introduced to her, yet there is little doubt in my mind that she is the killer, although she worked with both of the dead fables (Faith and Lily) I believe she is innocent as she gives hints to Bigby, although this could be a wild goose chase.

    Georgie: Sure, He's a pimp. Uncaring, rude and unwilling to cooperate on solving the murder, but I believe he is innocent, as again, it would be too cliche.

    Finally, the ONE FABLE I have had in mind from the beginning that noone else has yet suspected or investigated....TOAD

    Toad: Now who would suspect the quiet, innocent, always calling for the Sheriff toad that gets beat up and has people sneaking through HIS APARTMENTS (Dee). Now although Dee said Faith stole something from his boss (which we are not yet sure what it was, yet I believe it would accelerate dramatically the crimes, acting as a crucial part of evidence) he was still snooping around the apartment, and may have been coached to tell Bigby he was looking for a stolen item. Now although I said the Woodsman was the first character that is a suspect, the VERY FIRST CHARACTER apart from Bigby that we are introduced to is Toad, which obviously has a grudge on Bigby shown through his attitude as Bigby keeps telling him to get a glamour "Dont make me ask again" in the opening sequence of episode one. in MOST GAMES, there is a CRUCIAL part played in the opening sequence, which noone surprisingly seems to have picked up on. Thus, I am naming Toad as a #SUSPECT

    Personally, believe what you want. Those are my suspicions and opinions at this point of time, please feel free to clarify me in any false information provided or any missed information which can also narrow down the list of suspects.

  • edited February 2014

    I was suspicious of Toad too. But what about Tweedledee? If you go after the Woodsman instead of Dee in the bar..you can check out where the twins are by using the magic mirror. When you look into the mirror...you see Tweedledee next to a bottle of wine...the same wine from inside room 207. How did he get in there without a key? and why were photos of Crane planted inside the room so exposed and obviously? The tarot cards play a mighty role..which is the reason why I think that Crane isn't my prime suspect because there is some form of deception going on.

  • Very good perception skills, please visit my discussion thread if you have more theories. Also, I have added more information on each character, so be sure to view it. But in response, if you go after Dee, then there might be The Axeman doing something similar in the Magic Mirror. Unless it's Dee's brother, Dum. But I believe they are all trying to figure out who did this aswell. Or have reasons of they're own for participating
    http://www.telltalegames.com/community/discussion/59363/detailed-list-of-potential-killers

    sirxchrish posted: »

    I was suspicious of Toad too. But what about Tweedledee? If you go after the Woodsman instead of Dee in the bar..you can check out w

  • Don't know why that got a Thumbs down... I could say it is the Killer

    SaltLick305 posted: »

    The Headless Horseman MakesSense

  • might..

    Maybe, but he might show up again in future episodes.

  • Jack is harmless. He would not kill anyone

    Art2Heart posted: »

    My sibling doesn't trust Beast or Beauty and think they are both in it together, lol. They also said they suspect Jack Horner becaus

  • The deception would be at the Woodlands. The hermit is once you are at Georgie's Club. Hence the hermit has an ending and not just a beginning.

    sirxchrish posted: »

    I was suspicious of Toad too. But what about Tweedledee? If you go after the Woodsman instead of Dee in the bar..you can check out w

  • I think bluebeard or someone from cops. I mean the title is The Wolf Among Us ... - i think devs want players to thing the title is about Bigby (cos his wolf) but i think it also maybe referred as Killer Among us - like a wolf in sheep's clothing

  • I think Grendal, the darts were missing from the bar, that could be used to make track marks, plus he's one of the only people with the strength to fight lilly, since he's another troll, also he doesn't exist in the fable series, so he's been created just for the video game, implying that he's expendable.

Sign in to comment in this discussion.