Could their be another big bad wolf out there and could he/she be the killer

If you guys remember in the comic book snow gave bigby a knife with an enchantment that would let men walk as wolves or, as the original owner had claimed, vice versa could it be possible that someone got the knife somehow and used it to turn into a wolf and start killing people. if you guys remember in episode 2 beauty said that she thought that only bigby smoked huff and puffs but there it was found at the crime scene. ( it could be possible that someone is trying to frame bigby by planting the smokes their but I find that highly unlikely) what do you guys think could there be a another wolf out there in the woodlands?


  • The field is wide open at this point (especially considering there's magic involved), but I think what's going on is that some mundy has discovered the what the Fables really are and is trying to become one of them, specifically a wolf like Bigby. The Huff & Puff cigarettes could simply be what the culprit used to both feel like Bigby and to help along the fantasy that "Snow" will like him if he shares the habits Bigby does. Considering the year the game is set in, leaving the cigarettes isn't that incriminating because DNA testing has yet to be established as admissible in court, and the butt is not likely to have a latent finger print, so it might not necessarily be intended to implicate Bigby himself, but rather something that can be forgotten because it's not a very strong piece of evidence - unless Huff & Puff is a Fabletown exclusive product, but I doubt that.

  • Sorry, but no. This theory is bunk.

    I normally don't outright say no to a theory but this one is not going to be correct. An "evil twin" scenario is one of the most cliche and overused mechanic of a story, and Telltale won't go that route. It's the type of plot device a 7 year old can come up with and wouldn't reflect too well on their writers professionalism. Enough said.

Sign in to comment in this discussion.