Hardest Decision? (Spoilers)

edited March 2014 in The Walking Dead

Alt text Anyways, the latest episode of TWD was awesome, a lot of events happened, and we met new characters, but then there's also decisions, so just like the title said, what in your opinion was the hardest decision in episode 2?

«1

Comments

  • Choosing which table to sit at.

  • Dammit, beat me to it

    Arbitrator posted: »

    Choosing which table to sit at.

  • take the shot. only grazed him. -_-

  • edited March 2014

    I think going out to Kenny or giving up. It's really hard to imagine what could happen either way. There is no "smart" choice.

    Giving up might or might not save Carlos and might end up putting you in danger. But then again, why would Carver hurt you? You haven't done anything to piss him off, yet. Still, ending up as a hostage is always a bad situation.

    Then on the other hand there is the "sneak out" option. It might or might not save Carlos, but at least Clem herself would be safe. However, you have no weapon and the enemy is heavily armed. If they end up catching you, this might turn out bad for you. It has the possibility to save everyone, but also has the high chance of screwing things up even more. It's a high risk.

  • Hardest decision was deciding wether or not for kenny to take the shot... Shot carver..grazed him.. Killed Alvin.. Restarted game.

  • Carlos lives regardless

    I think going out to Kenny or giving up. It's really hard to imagine what could happen either way. There is no "smart" choice.

  • yeah, but you don't know that at first.

    Carlos lives regardless

  • I'm super ashamed of it, but I did the same thing. I just couldn't live with that

    Legendary12 posted: »

    Hardest decision was deciding wether or not for kenny to take the shot... Shot carver..grazed him.. Killed Alvin.. Restarted game.

  • I really thought he was going to die...

    Carlos lives regardless

  • I stayed like 5 minutes there wondering.. In the end I went to Luke's table, I don't know, the "new" Kenny seems very strange.

    Arbitrator posted: »

    Choosing which table to sit at.

  • edited March 2014

    The hardest decision was whether to surrender or sneak out to find Luke and Kenny. I ultimately went to find Kenny(with almost no time left in the timer...), and Walter died. Not sure if you can prevent that, but I guess at least we got Johnny? I told Kenny not to take the second shot, I really didn't want to lose anyone else...

    Also, did Luke just fucking bail on them? Where the hell was he!?

  • edited March 2014

    Same choice, but then my heart broke when Kenny looked back with that face...... Kenny will remember that

  • When they make you choose with whom you sit with at the table.

    GAH!

    If you stay with Kenny,Luke does the bambi eyes.

    If you stay with Luke,Kenny seems angry.

    I CAN'T!!!

  • So wait whatever you do carlos lives??

    Zyphon posted: »

    I really thought he was going to die...

  • So just dont let Kenny take the shots??

    Zyphon posted: »

    The hardest decision was whether to surrender or sneak out to find Luke and Kenny. I ultimately went to find Kenny(with almost no

  • If you don't choose anything, he dies.

    So wait whatever you do carlos lives??

  • That's a non-canon death though, right?

    If you don't choose anything, he dies.

  • Well, apparently Carver kills Walter regardless, so taking the first shot that kills Johnny won't really change much, but if you take the second shot and graze Carver, then he kills Alvin. I took the first shot, but told Kenny to give up when he was about to kill Alvin.

    So just dont let Kenny take the shots??

  • I haven't seen that happen, yet. But it seems like the story continues, so it's a valid choice I think.

    Zyphon posted: »

    That's a non-canon death though, right?

  • That was the worst

    Azlyn posted: »

    When they make you choose with whom you sit with at the table. GAH! If you stay with Kenny,Luke does the bambi eyes. If you stay with Luke,Kenny seems angry. I CAN'T!!!

  • I decided to sit with Luke. He seemed to be more alone than Kenny. Nick was an unstable mess and liability and Luke doesn't seem too enthusiastic about the rest of his group. Kenny, however, had his new significant other and a good group behind him, so I thought he could stand to miss out on having Clem's company.

    Luke needed the morale boost!

    (Dat moment when Kenny calls Clem 'Duck' though. ;_; I was waiting for the moment when I could give him the drawing of his family I didn't burn in Chapter 1, but, alas, it never came.)

    Arbitrator posted: »

    Choosing which table to sit at.

  • So can you save Johnny

    Zyphon posted: »

    Well, apparently Carver kills Walter regardless, so taking the first shot that kills Johnny won't really change much, but if you t

  • edited March 2014

    The where to sit choice
    I choose Kenny cuz its so obvious that he will be mad/sad if not . and i noticed that it shows that luke was sad but i didn't notice any " Luke will remember that " ( or did i miss it ? correct me if im wrong ) and my friend choose to sit next to Luke and so it was " Kenny will remember that " which means it comes bite u in the ass if ur gonna need him .

  • I just had to sit with Kenny; I mean Clem though he was dead so she needed to spend time with him. I know how Clem felt when choosing a table, cuz this happens all the time with me.

  • Choosing who to sit next to at the table definitely

  • Remember if you surrendered first, then Carver takes Alvin hostage, you can run at Carver to save him, Carver notices her and hits her hard throws Alvin to the side and he takes her hostage instead with a gun to her head.

    I think going out to Kenny or giving up. It's really hard to imagine what could happen either way. There is no "smart" choice.

  • My god, the Surrender or find Kenny Situation. I mean I was scared if Carlos or anyone would get killed. I did my best to save everyone, but Walter died regardless. I'm gonna kill that sonofabitch Carver!

  • Alvin and Nick are determinant and canon,though.Alvin died in my file and I don't really care because he had no character developpement,but Nick did,and I like him.Im very happy he's still alive.

    I haven't seen that happen, yet. But it seems like the story continues, so it's a valid choice I think.

  • Indeed it was,user that looks just like old Kenny.

    That was the worst

  • The surrender or sneak out situation, man....I was sweating so hard from all the stress, cause I thought Carlos was gonna die!

  • I can tell you one thing, to me, this season already beats the previous in terms of situational impact, I mean holy cow this episode was another emotional ride for me.

    MrSolomon posted: »

    The surrender or sneak out situation, man....I was sweating so hard from all the stress, cause I thought Carlos was gonna die!

  • Why would you want to?

    So can you save Johnny

  • Well... No. Also, it's not really "Saving Johnny". I mean, he's one of the bad guys...

    But no, Johnny dies regardless.

    So can you save Johnny

  • Deciding rather to sneak out and find help or just give up and surrender. Really wish I would of gave up now because I told Kenny to shoot Carver and it ended up getting my dog Alvin killed.

  • Kenny's table versus Luke's.

  • I think the majority of players agree that choosing which table to sit at has been one of the hardest this season. It seems so strange to think that choosing a table to sit at is such a hard choice, but it really was.

  • Same. I was all SHOOT!!!!

    multicolt posted: »

    take the shot. only grazed him. -_-

  • edited March 2014

    That was one of the smartest choices TellTale put in the game. They wanted to test your loyalty with a character that you've been knowing since the first season and one that you've known recently. It means that even the smallest and the most stupid thing, like deciding whom to sit with, really DOES matter.

    TellTale you're masters!

    I think the majority of players agree that choosing which table to sit at has been one of the hardest this season. It seems so strange to think that choosing a table to sit at is such a hard choice, but it really was.

  • biggest thing for me was based on the preview from episode 1. seeing mathew and walter standing next to eachother during the confrontation at the lodge. i went back over from the dinner scene to the bridge about 7 times trying to see if there was something i was missing to keep nick from shooting. nothing worked. same goes for trying to give pete the time he needed to say his goodbyes to nick. always the same thing, which considering i left pete in the car's front seat one of the runs through, seeing the back doors open and blood on the wrong side of the vehicle... it just looked off.

  • Same here.

    I'm super ashamed of it, but I did the same thing. I just couldn't live with that

Sign in to comment in this discussion.