Nick's A Good Guy

edited March 2014 in The Walking Dead

How many times was this brought up throughout the episode?

Nick did save me by distracting the walkers or Pete told you he was but When i had to answer the question i kind of said it half-hearted some truth behind but still doubt.


  • I don't know why Carlos thinks he "Is becoming a danger to the group" :P

  • He's definitively a good guy. He admitted his guilt, regretted his actions and had the balls to face the consequences head-on. Only a good person can do that.

  • If only you could do an accent through typing :p

  • Nick is a good guy, but he's also a fuck up. That doesn't matter much to me since he's willing to own his mistakes and make up for them, the situation with Matthew being a perfect example when it comes time to tell Walter. The characters in the game however, excluding Pete and Luke, probably focus more on his mistakes than how he reacts to them, as he's made some big ones.

  • I would be so happy :P This Carlos impersonation would be the best meme ever !

  • Lol, Carlos never said that, Nick just assumed it.

  • He really is like Ben. Both are warmed-hearted people, but just always fuck up no matter how hard they try to help.

  • edited March 2014

    Well Ben was a " good guy " aswell and i decided " let him go ". The only reason i saved Nicks life is because i promised my good old friend uncle Pete to watch after him before he sacrificed himself to save my life.

    I will make one of these for Nick when Season2 is over! :D

  • DeceptioDeceptio Banned
    edited March 2014

    I really hate it when people let Ben go. Just because people are liabilities doesn't mean they deserve to die. Ben and Nick are both good people, and are guilty and depressed. They want to help but they always fuck up. People who let Ben go and let Nick die because they are "liabilities" are assholes.

  • I know, Im just running with it cause its funny !

  • edited March 2014

    Thats your own my opinion Ben was a danger to the group, just like Nick is a danger to the cabin group. And also, Ben didn't want to life anymore...he told me to let him go and that's what i did.

  • Well, I can't argue with that.

  • Come on, everyone laughed at that scene, LOL.

  • edited March 2014

    Nick is a good guy, just like Ben was. As others have said, they are both just fuck up's at times. Doesn't mean that they are evil people.

    I liked the part where you give the watch to Nick. I knew that taking the watch had some significance down the line somewhere. It meant a lot to Nick because it was the only thing that reminded him of Pete.

  • Dammit Nick Im liking you too much ! Thats bad cause people with Determinant statuses don't last long..

  • edited March 2014

    Why can't you argue with that? I told you my opinion and my opinion has alot of reasonable and logical points, just like yours does.

    People have their own different opinions on certain things...that's what makes this game series so special!

  • I couldn't argue with your opinion because it had a lot of good points.

  • Well, Carley/Doug were determinant and they lived for 3 episodes. :D

  • Ah i see...sorry i got that wrong then :D

  • Sanders12Sanders12 Banned
    edited March 2014

    Nick was just like everyone else. He was a real fuck up.

  • Ben was more cowardly than Nick. Unlike Ben, Nick can deal with Walkers, or even the living as shown by the situation with Matthew, while Ben usually either did nothing or ran away in Season 1.

    They both fuck up the same, though.

  • edited March 2014

    I agree Nick is a good guy but also a screw up but lets be honest I dont think he's anywhere near Ben's level, Ben is in his own league with amount of fuckery he's been able to accomplish. I mean come on causing the death of (almost) a whole group indirectly, while Nick accidently killed a random guy and almost shot clem, in my book he has long way to go before officially becoming ben 2.0 just saying. :P

  • edited March 2014

    I now know that Nick is a good guy, but I still was really mad at him after he shot Matthew. So when Walter was questioning me, I said Nick didn't do it, but eventually it got to him. So when he asked what Nick was really like, my mind, still on the bridge incident, said he wasn't the best guy. So he's gone. Just another stone I have to swallow.

    EDIT: Ya know, I think my profile picture should be Nick, to carry out his legacy! AT least for me.

  • The question is, If Nick isn't Ben 2.0 then who is?

  • Yea, Nick is a good guy. Luke told me to hide the evidence of Nick's actions. He tried even to not let Nick know what he did. When he found out, he was making the right choice by wanting to be honest, and tell the truth of what happened and he did. The weird thing is that when Ben admits what he did, then we're given the choice to threaten him or just talk to him about what happened, and tell him to keep it to himself. With Nick you're given the choice to speak out. So I told Walter the truth, and Nick actually are honest, and take responsibility. While Luke of course wants Nick to get away with murder. I think this situation really shows a bad side of Luke, and a good side of Nick.

  • I think theres a big difference between them.
    For example in Ep04 when Ben and Clem were surrounded by walkers and he just ran away like a pss, whereas Nick was ready to sacrifice himself to save her.
    And Nick just "fuck up" once with the Matthew thing but Ben did it numerous times.
    Im not saying Ben is a bad character, i liked him and saved him in my playthrough, im just saying he and Nick really are not the same.

  • Nick isn't really a fuck up. Honestly, if we count all the things he has done wrong. He really isn't that bad. He shot a guy that had a gun thinking he was protecting us. It was resolved without any deaths (accept for maybe Nick's own life), or any real consequences to the group. Pete was already doomed for death when he got bit too, so even if Nick would of saved him he was dead meat.
    If Nick is a fuck up, then what about Clementine letting Carver in the Cabin when she was supposed to protect it? Or when Kenny (depending on how you played the game) got Walter,Alvin or even Carlos killed because he wasn't thinking? Or how Luke wasn't there for the group like Kenny was to try and protect it?
    Just because Nick has some qualities like Ben doesn't mean anything. Nick is truly a good guy, like everybody else in this new group.

  • I told Walter the truth because he was gonna find out anyway. It also says in the wiki that Walter and Matthew were "Partners" so could that mean they both were gay?

  • For clementine it varies because for me I chose to lock it
    But he opened it before she could (determinately)

  • True that. That's exactly what happened to me. (Who forgot to lock the thing anyways?)

Sign in to comment in this discussion.