This discussion may contain spoilers!
I know we're going a long way back but I just need to express an idea of what should've happened.
After the scene where Rebecca threatens Clem after Luke and Pete left, followed by Rebecca; I wished they gave us a chance to walk around the cabin and talk to others then when enter Nick's room, he'll let her sleep on his bed while he sleeps downstairs. As Clem sits down on the bed she takes off her hat and sets it down on the end table. As she lays down, she looks at her hat, remembering her family and Lee, causing her to cry a little before going to sleeping. This would've been a very emotional scene and probably be a important one as well.
Just a thought, hope you liked it. I'll draw it out sometime(god knows when that'll be cuz comic work can be a pain). Maybe Telltale can consider this in future episodes, except it wont be entirely the same.
UPDATED VERSION HERE!
Okie dokie guys! Thanks for bumping this thread back up again! I couldn't find the damn thing once I figured my altered version of this. Well without further a due here it is!
When Rebecca leaves the kitchen, Clem would finish her food then get up to put the bowl in the sink. So the gameplay starts where you can walk around the kitchen inspecting everything, you can even look out the window. Now if Sarah lend you her book you have the option to grab it so you can around with Clem holding the book, this would be kinda important. So after you're done all that you can leave the kitchen.
In the main room you can see Luke sitting with Rebecca on the couch, Alvin and Carlos will be talking by the wall. By the door where Carver first arrives you can see Pete looking out, you can ask him how is it out there, and you talk to him about the idea of chopping her arm off from before. You can try to talk to Alvin but Bec would glare at him so he ignores Clem, unintentionally. For Carlos you can talk to him about the shed, his doctor experience(these first two is only available if Clem apologized to him) and you can give him the book Sarah gave you(optional if you grabbed it) he would appreciate this. Now you can go to Luke and Bec where you can hear Luke telling Bec to give Clem a chance at least. Clem will ask where she can sleep so Luke will lead her upstairs.
Up here Luke will stand by the door where it has Pete's watch is(or was), there will be a small hub moment. If you still have the book Luke will mention Clem should probably give it back to Sarah. Here you can go to Sarah's room and see her, there won't be any dialogue choices though UNLESS you have Sarah's book in your hands still. Clem will give Sarah the book back and she'll ask how Clem liked it where you have several dialogue choices, followed by another before you leave where you can say [Thank you] [Goodnight Sarah] [Silent]. After that you will go to Luke and he'll knock the door, Nick will open it and Luke will ask if Clem can sleep on his bed. Nick's decision will be based on your forgiveness choice earlier on.
If you denied his apology will say no cause he's a little pissed still, Luke would argue with him for a sec but Nick will then shut the door. You will see Carlos coming up and going into Sarah's room; Luke will take Clem downstairs so she can sleep on the couch(which Luke sleeps on). Luke and Clem will be downstairs where you can see Pete going into the kitchen to sleep, Luke will sit on the chair and Clem will sit on the couch. Luke will blow out the candles when Clem takes off her hat. Luke will then joke how messy Clem's hair is, Clem would get a little insulted but then smile after realizing he's just teasing. Luke would apologize about Nick and Clem can say [It's alright] [Nick is kind of a dick] [I think I should've been a little nicer that moment.]. For special responses if you choose [Nick is kind of a dick] Luke would laugh and partially agree but he's a real good guy at heart, give him time. If you choose [I think I should've been a little nicer that moment], he'll say there's nothing she can do, just try to make up for it I guess. Clem can agree or say same goes for him too. Afterwards Luke will go to sleep and Clem will lay down, and look at her hat and have a sad look on her before going to sleep.
If you forgave him, Nick will let Clem come in, Luke will then leave. Nick tells Clem she can sleep on his bed, Clem can say [Okay, thanks.] [What about you?]. A little special dialogue with Nick will appear if you ask [What about you?], he'll say he'll sleep on the floor, he can't stand sleeping on chairs. Anyway Clem will take off her hat and it on the side then she'll lay down on the bed and Nick will lay on the floor, Nick will comment her hat, she'll compliment his. They'll talk about how they got their hats, you learn Nick got his in the arcade when he an Luke went to high school. Nick will then go to sleep and you can see Clem looking at her hat, remembering Lee and her family, she'll cry a little before she goes to sleep.