This discussion may contain spoilers!
I was surprised at the number of people who gave the dying man water, knowing that he ambushed christa. I'd like to know why? My guess is that most of you thought you'd use it as a bargaining tool to find the whereabouts of Christa? I thought the same but I figured he'd have to give me some info first before I gave him water (hence why i didn't give him any), and I felt good about my decision when pete needed some water.
Also, the watch. For those who had either the watch or water, Did you give water to pete/the dying man, or save it for self. If you took the watch, did you give it to nick?
I like how telltale is allowing us to save some of these for later. I just can't always decide if keeping it is best.