This discussion may contain spoilers!
I beat season one over 6 times, and every time I see the percentage of people who DID NOT kill BOTH of the St. Johns brothers, I am shocked! Who WOULDN'T, and for what reasons? On your FIRST play through, which did you kill if not both? Did you kill both? Did you spare both, why? I want to know the first play through choice when you DIDN'T know/think about clementine seeing it.
In my eyes, they were crazy, knew where the motor inn was, and could easily come back to kill the group at a later day, hence why I am dying to know why so many thought it was okay to spare either one.