Cluke...

edited April 2014 in The Walking Dead

Yes 'Cluke' has been discussed before but how did Cluke even start? It boggles the mind that people think it's a good idea. Everyone has the right to their opinion but still... it's just too much of an age difference. If you didn't know, Luke is supposedly in his mid to late twenties. Making him twice or possibly almost three times her age and making him roughly 16 years older than her, which means whenever she was a fetus, he was 16. Would you let a 16 year old date a fetus? I may be an asshole for thinking about it like this but I just can't support Cluke, it doesn't seem right. I love the character Luke and I love the character Clementine but just stop the Cluke stuff... please...

** By the way, I may seem like a bitch but I mean well. I really don't want Clementine with a nearly thirty year old man, and i'm not crazy for thinking about it like that.

«13456713

Comments

  • I must say, well said

  • I agree a 100 percent on that I think the people who even thought up the idea should have the FBI look into their internet history

  • Yes, they have a brother/sister relationship and I do like them as a team (not as great a team as Lee and Clem though). There have already been a lot of threads about this before but I also can't support Cluke.

  • Especially those of which who have written fan fictions about it... I really haven't looked at any fan fictions of that but i've heard they exist and with how many people support it, i'm not surprised.

    drsjohnny posted: »

    I agree a 100 percent on that I think the people who even thought up the idea should have the FBI look into their internet history

  • I agree on the team thing. I think they have an adorable brother/sister relationship but never did I once think about romance with the two of them.

    ChocoHallic posted: »

    Yes, they have a brother/sister relationship and I do like them as a team (not as great a team as Lee and Clem though). There have already been a lot of threads about this before but I also can't support Cluke.

  • edited April 2014

    It really is sad for people to think of a fictional 11 year old girl like this, like that thread about Clementine getting pregnant.

  • edited April 2014

    I think some people didn't understand what I meant when I posted this comment. I was just saying that you should ignore that Cluke shit and this subject won't be touched. That's all.

  • Is bringing it up and giving it more attention going to help? Nope.

  • There are people with paraphilia of sorts when it comes to this kind of thing, definitely. I wouldn't judge them, considering that I have a paraphilia of another kind which I'm not gonna disclose (but it's got nothing to do with children, if you must know). But with this kind of controversial stuff, it's expected that people are naturally going to have a knee-jerk reaction.

    I personally found Cluke to be awkward as well. I don't see them as a thing together, canon-wise. But I could understand why those who thought otherwise did so. It's a thing with the Japanese too.

    _Juice_Box_ posted: »

    Especially those of which who have written fan fictions about it... I really haven't looked at any fan fictions of that but i've heard they exist and with how many people support it, i'm not surprised.

  • Most people who ship Cluke are teen/pre-teen girls that think Luke is cute. It's sick, but one day they will understand. Hopefully.

  • I didn't know about that thread... and i'm not sure I want to O_O

    ShaneWalsh posted: »

    It really is sad for people to think of a fictional 11 year old girl like this, like that thread about Clementine getting pregnant.

  • edited April 2014

    It's better than letting them think it's okay. I have the right to spread my opinion just as much as they have the right to spread theirs, even though I strongly disagree.

    Is bringing it up and giving it more attention going to help? Nope.

  • edited April 2014

    I just don't understand the whole Cluke thing...I agree with you, it just doesn't make any sense, he's obviously a lot older than she is and Clem is still a kid so why even bother to do the whole Cluke thing? I think we as a community feel like parents for Clementine, a lot of us don't want her to be in a relationship any time soon, especially with someone who is way older than her, that's just wrong.

  • I agree wholeheartedly; TT seems to be going for a older/younger sibling relationship with Luke and Clem, and that's definitely how it should be.

    But for my two cents on your original question, I've seen other posters comment on the look of pride and accomplishment Clem and Luke give each other after dispatching the two walkers at the bridge's entrance. Maybe some interpreted Cluke from that exchange of emotions, or mixed up the emotions.

  • No one thinks it's okay. They are trolls and feeding them won't help.

    _Juice_Box_ posted: »

    It's better than letting them think it's okay. I have the right to spread my opinion just as much as they have the right to spread theirs, even though I strongly disagree.

  • edited April 2014

    Except that you seem to be offended by them when they spread their opinion.

    Hey, I'm just saying man. Equal rights for everybody.

    _Juice_Box_ posted: »

    It's better than letting them think it's okay. I have the right to spread my opinion just as much as they have the right to spread theirs, even though I strongly disagree.

  • Yeah, I don't get why people ship them like that. I wonder if people shipped Leementine during S1? Or if The Last Of Us fans ship Joellie?

  • edited April 2014

    You sure? I won't leave out any "juicy deets". As Nate would say. lol

    Just kidding you!

    _Juice_Box_ posted: »

    I didn't know about that thread... and i'm not sure I want to O_O

  • You're wrong there. I've met so many actual Clukers. I wish they were trolling but a good most of them are being legitimate.

    No one thinks it's okay. They are trolls and feeding them won't help.

  • edited April 2014

    I am actually the same age as Luke, and i'm just saying from personal experience that I don't find 11 year old girls attractive. I honestly am worried by the amount of potential pedophiles on this forum, seriously people need to stop talking about who Clem is and is not shipping with it's abhorrent. And even when Clem is 18 why are people still thinking about who Clem should ship with, this is Clementine for crying out loud.

  • There's always something freaking wrong with people when they're shipping. It's like Joel and Ellie from The Last of Us... or Booker and Elizabeth from Bioshock Infinite O.O

    No seriously, those were legitimate ships at one point.

  • edited April 2014

    Alt text

    Everytime see cluke thread ^

    Though only one who is confused by whole Cluke thing just weird and technically makes Luke a pedo just can't understand why people talk or make threads about it just weird and sick

  • Theres nothing wrong with this thread. Its just their opinion. If threads like these bother anyone, then they shouldn't answer them anyway.

    Except that you seem to be offended by them when they spread their opinion. Hey, I'm just saying man. Equal rights for everybody.

  • And for that reason, she's allowed to use that right to spread her opinion, whether or not it offends the offenders.

    Except that you seem to be offended by them when they spread their opinion. Hey, I'm just saying man. Equal rights for everybody.

  • edited April 2014

    You are right, they fancy him and probably just want to see more erm of him, I'm sure a lot of guys wanted to see more of Carley but that ended tragically.

    Most people who ship Cluke are teen/pre-teen girls that think Luke is cute. It's sick, but one day they will understand. Hopefully.

  • I just like to tell my opinion about the people that I see as slightly mentally sick.

    Markd4547 posted: »

    Everytime see cluke thread ^ Though only one who is confused by whole Cluke thing just weird and technically makes Luke a pedo just can't understand why people talk or make threads about it just weird and sick

  • Yes 'Cluke' has been discussed before but how did Cluke even start?

    Lexiporter.

  • Alt text

    AusZombie posted: »

    I am actually the same age as Luke, and i'm just saying from personal experience that I don't find 11 year old girls attractive. I

  • SAME HERE!! and then I saw all the Cluke threads and I was like, "whyyy??........."

    _Juice_Box_ posted: »

    I agree on the team thing. I think they have an adorable brother/sister relationship but never did I once think about romance with the two of them.

  • Exactly, I'm pretty sure they just want to see him take his shirt off. :p

    ShaneWalsh posted: »

    You are right, they fancy him and probably just want to see more erm of him, I'm sure a lot of guys wanted to see more of Carley but that ended tragically.

  • You do have a point, i'll give you that and as much as I do want people to not be mistreated, it's difficult to feel sympathy for a group of people who have members that want to see a Cluke sex scene.

    Except that you seem to be offended by them when they spread their opinion. Hey, I'm just saying man. Equal rights for everybody.

  • I'd agree though, that opening that whole can of worms again isn't a very wise thing to do. It's a controversial topic, whether you like to admit it or not. Pedophilia is a very mature subject and just dismissing or demonising it isn't going to help anyone. It's a real psychological disorder that affects people and their lives, their families. Starting this kind of thread just leads people to say unnecessary and insensitive things like how so-and-so is a sickf*** or whatever. We don't need that kind of drama down here.

    _Juice_Box_ posted: »

    You're wrong there. I've met so many actual Clukers. I wish they were trolling but a good most of them are being legitimate.

  • Yeah, Thats true

    _Juice_Box_ posted: »

    You do have a point, i'll give you that and as much as I do want people to not be mistreated, it's difficult to feel sympathy for a group of people who have members that want to see a Cluke sex scene.

  • OzzyUKOzzyUK Moderator
    edited April 2014

    These threads are what started all this "cluke" nonsense http://www.telltalegames.com/community/discussion/56568/clem-has-a-crush-on-luke/p1

    http://www.telltalegames.com/community/discussion/54951/the-lukescott-porter-thread/p1

    Its not a good idea to talk about who started them as they are now banned so just read the crazyness on the old threads.

  • lol sorry didn't mean you just in generally no this is brilliant thread

    _Juice_Box_ posted: »

    I just like to tell my opinion about the people that I see as slightly mentally sick.

  • Fangirls, they will come up with some crazy stuffs...cause they need to ship something...sometimes even canon stuffs is not enough for them.
    Really
    its the fangirls
    just
    the
    fangirls
    okay?
    ok.

  • I understand. It is a disturbing notion for normal people, and it's a tough subject to treat upon objectively and maturely. Which is even more reason why such a thread shouldn't be started in the first place.

    _Juice_Box_ posted: »

    You do have a point, i'll give you that and as much as I do want people to not be mistreated, it's difficult to feel sympathy for a group of people who have members that want to see a Cluke sex scene.

  • Look, I may come off as a complete bitch by writing these sorts of things out, but I just don't feel comfortable with their 'cause' or whatever it is they're trying to put out there. I'm not homophobic, i'm not against an 18 year old dating a 27 year old, i'm not against a black person marrying a white person and creating mixed children, but I just don't feel right not reacting to people who think it's a good idea for someone who's 11 to be with someone who's almost triple that age.

    There are people with paraphilia of sorts when it comes to this kind of thing, definitely. I wouldn't judge them, considering that

  • Please stop bringing it up...

  • Good point.

    I'd agree though, that opening that whole can of worms again isn't a very wise thing to do. It's a controversial topic, whether yo

This discussion has been closed.