Why it might be Clementine...

Ok so... let me explain... Of course I don't want Clementine to get beat up but let me just say, in the screenshot you see Carver has the walkie-talkie that you see in the "Not in Nottingham" and the "Always The Quiet Ones" achievements. I point this out because the description of "Not in Nottingham" is in fact "Got Beaten Down".

A lot of people think it means Kenny since in the trailer you see Carver hit Kenny (which will probably still happen) but the text is always going to be in first person of the playable character, which is obviously Clementine.

Alt text

Alt text

This MIGHT mean that she'll be the one being beaten down.

«1

Comments

  • Hmm... very very plausible. Good job juicy. By the way, nice profile picture.

  • Am I the only one that sees a hat and hair that looks like Kenny's? I think it's Kenny.

  • The hair does look like Kenny's hair but the hat is different.

    Mr_Eeuss posted: »

    Am I the only one that sees a hat and hair that looks like Kenny's? I think it's Kenny.

  • Carver's other hand looks like it's grabbing on to something?

  • I have been trying to avoid as many achievement related spoilers as possible but this is a little hard to avoid. All I have to say is MaxNeverDies is an absolute wanker and I hope he grows up sooner rather then later.

  • Looks a bit like one of Clementine's pigtails?

    Carver's other hand looks like it's grabbing on to something?

  • I wouldn't count on it. Telltale would've never shown this picture if that was indeed him. And judging by how bloody Carver is, that person is not getting up, whoever it might be.

    Mr_Eeuss posted: »

    Am I the only one that sees a hat and hair that looks like Kenny's? I think it's Kenny.

  • Jenny_PitcherJenny_Pitcher Banned
    edited May 2014

    Shape of head/face says it's Sarah.

    Alt text

  • I don't think so. I think he's just clenching his fist.

    Carver's other hand looks like it's grabbing on to something?

  • edited May 2014

    Edit:It's not I edited and it looks like someone else
    Alt text

  • More Misery Porn from TT

  • Hmm... it does look like him but why the blue hat? Isn't his hat red?

    poplee posted: »

    Edit:It's not I edited and it looks like someone else

  • edited May 2014

    Indeed, Kenny's hat is brown. But then again it seems like there's a bluish shadow over the person getting beaten up. The only characters with a hat are Nick, Clem and Kenny. Nick's hair doesn't match, and I don't think Clem could take such brutal beating. So that leaves us with Kenny.

    _Juice_Box_ posted: »

    The hair does look like Kenny's hair but the hat is different.

  • Maybe, but I kinda doubt it's Clem. Why would he pummel a moldable and useful kid? Even if she steals, Carver is probably smart enough to realize that he could punish/hurt Clementine a lot worse by beating/killing somebody she cares about and forcing her to watch..

  • I know that but the hair is the same it might be someone new.

    Clem_TWDG posted: »

    Hmm... it does look like him but why the blue hat? Isn't his hat red?

  • My thoughts exactly. That person is either dead or their face is completely smashed (which is probably a death sentence anyway).

    I wouldn't count on it. Telltale would've never shown this picture if that was indeed him. And judging by how bloody Carver is, that person is not getting up, whoever it might be.

  • That's plausible.

    poplee posted: »

    I know that but the hair is the same it might be someone new.

  • edited May 2014

    We have no idea who the person in that screenshot is. We have no idea whether this is suposed to be the murder or the beating. We have no proof that it's Clem, but we know she's gonna get beaten down anyway. It might be the same person who committed larceny or maybe not. Might be someone who's covering for him/her. Who knows. Maybe we should make like a billion more threads about this until episode 3 where we can get a definitive answer.

  • CathalOHaraCathalOHara Moderator

    Man, I can imagine the critics will be shocked and pissed at this. Since in the past year, it's apparently cool to give something a low score.

  • Good point :P

    Baldex posted: »

    We have no idea who the person in that screenshot is. We have no idea whether this is suposed to be the murder or the beating. We

  • Could just be a new guy but that's wishful thinking :P

    Mr_Eeuss posted: »

    Indeed, Kenny's hat is brown. But then again it seems like there's a bluish shadow over the person getting beaten up. The only cha

  • edited May 2014

    I think it is one of Clem's pigtails. you can see that he is grabbing something and not clenching his fist. It may be a coincidence but if he is pulling on her hair it would make sense that in the slide for episode 4 she has her hair down with no pigtails...

    _Juice_Box_ posted: »

    Looks a bit like one of Clementine's pigtails?

  • I know people will be pissed at this but I don't think people will give it a low score. I mean someone will, no matter how good the episode is but I'd like to think they wouldn't do that JUST because it's basically child abuse.

    CathalOHara posted: »

    Man, I can imagine the critics will be shocked and pissed at this. Since in the past year, it's apparently cool to give something a low score.

  • I sense this episode will be pretty upsetting...

    I think it is one of Clem's pigtails. you can see that he is grabbing something and not clenching his fist. It may be a coincidenc

  • That looks an awful lot like Clem in her new blue jacket to me. Plus we are seeing this from a first person point of view. Who else do we ever see from first person point of view? Clem is the only one. Here is my prediction: Carver finds out Clem stole the walkies, probably to communicate with Luke, and she is somehow responsible for the herd coming in. He's covered with blood from slaying walkers and is holding it up because he is mad enough to beat her down. Whether he actually does or not....man I can't even imagine. I hate him enough already but if he hits my Clem I hope they give me an option for the most inhumane death of Carver ever.

  • What if Clementine gets punched as Carver takes the walkie talkie, and then Kenny (Or another character depending on how you treat them) will step forward and protest and take the beating. The achievement image shows an eyeball looking at Carvers silhouette holding the walkie talkie, perhaps Clementine is on the ground writing in pain and only sees Carver beating up the person who stepped forward.

  • I hope you're right, I do NOT want that to be Clem! He looks so pissed :/

    Mr_Eeuss posted: »

    I don't think so. I think he's just clenching his fist.

  • Thanks! This is actually what I meant with the "Jumping to conclusions" post in one of other threads. Sorry if I came off as rude or anything.

    _Juice_Box_ posted: »

    Good point :P

  • Doesn't matter who it is, I'll still enjoy every minute of it.

  • Couldn't agree more. It will be upsetting but I think it'll only be a taste for what is to come in episode 4. I really fear that bad things will happen in Amid The Ruins.

    _Juice_Box_ posted: »

    I sense this episode will be pretty upsetting...

  • Then it's not Clem either. Unless Carver has already beaten up someone else (explaining the blood) and is now trying to hit Clem as well.

    I wouldn't count on it. Telltale would've never shown this picture if that was indeed him. And judging by how bloody Carver is, that person is not getting up, whoever it might be.

  • GOUSTTTTGOUSTTTT Banned
    edited May 2014

    I don't want her to get hurt but at the same time...I kinder do, Just hear me out, I don't see any reason why Clem should be invincible, Don't get me wrong, I do think she should survive but not without some scratches.

    _Juice_Box_ posted: »

    I know people will be pissed at this but I don't think people will give it a low score. I mean someone will, no matter how good the episode is but I'd like to think they wouldn't do that JUST because it's basically child abuse.

  • Kerrnerr

    poplee posted: »

    Edit:It's not I edited and it looks like someone else

  • No no, it takes a lot to offend me, don't worry :P
    Baldex posted: »

    Thanks! This is actually what I meant with the "Jumping to conclusions" post in one of other threads. Sorry if I came off as rude or anything.

  • edited May 2014
    I don't think it's Clem, Carver is a bad guy but not that kind of ''I slap the shit out of little eleven year old girls'' bad guy, See all the blood...
  • I completely agree. It's insane that people think she's just immune to harm. Not only is the episode called "In Harm's Way" but I think it just adds to her bad assery/awesomeness to have those times where she really just can't do anything about it. I'm not sure why but it just does IMO.
    GOUSTTTT posted: »

    I don't want her to get hurt but at the same time...I kinder do, Just hear me out, I don't see any reason why Clem should be invincible, Don't get me wrong, I do think she should survive but not without some scratches.

  • If you're going by achievements; Not in Nottingham occurs before Come Hither. Come Hither suggests that walkers are let into the compound by someone. In the new screenshots with Clem, then Clem and Sarah fighting walkers suggests that is after or during the Come Hither award. So if Clem got the beating for the Not in Nottingham achievement then wouldn't she have some kind of marks indicating the previous beat down in the screenshots with her fighting walkers?
  • AmazingAura01AmazingAura01 Banned
    edited May 2014
    Actually, it COULD be that guy with blue shirt and hat. Really look closely. Who else wears a blue hat in the game? No one. I think he's one of Carver's teammates. He might got bad at him and start fighting with him. And why do we all think all that blood is not Carver's own blood? http://i1232.photobucket.com/albums/ff365/AmazingAura01/xcv_zpsc5d89ad3.png
  • edited May 2014
    Clem where's a blue cap and you can see what looks like that little spacing (don't know what it's called) that's on the back of all baseball caps, including Clementine's.

    Also, good point about his blood and such although I don't see any other source.

    Actually, it COULD be that guy with blue shirt and hat. Really look closely. Who else wears a blue hat in the game? No one. I thin

  • edited May 2014
    This is what I thought. :)

    I speculated the blue hat could be Clem's and her hair could look like how it does because it's from a weird angle. I also noted that the blue collar could be that of her new jacket we see in the other screenshots.

    I don't want it to be Clem but it's looking like it might be, at least to me. :(
Sign in to comment in this discussion.