The achievement said "got beaten down." With either Troy or Carver standing over Clem holding a walkie talkie. My question is, do you think Troy will hurt Clem even more since it's probably him in the picture? The picture makes it looks like he's gonna punch Clem or something plus a beat down usually isn't just one hit. He probably caught her stealing the walkie talkies and hit her because before that she didn't have that cut on her face.