Rate Episode 3 (non-spoiler topic)

BenPaulBenPaul Banned
edited May 2014 in The Walking Dead
On a scale of 1 to 5, how would you rate episode 3?

Comments

  • 4.5
  • OzzyUKOzzyUK Moderator
    Same for me

    4.5

  • 2̶0̶0̶0̶. 9000
  • 5 it was freakin' awesome!!!
  • better than ep 2?
    Healoz posted: »

    5 it was freakin' awesome!!!

  • The rating for this episode is over 9000!!!
  • BenPaulBenPaul Banned
    i think so...
    Spagetto posted: »

    better than ep 2?

  • 5, never had I been so toyed with my emotions. My heart was beating for the entire episode.
  • 0,0000000000000000001/5. Really!?? Shorter than Vince story and the most annoying ending I have ever seen??!!!!
  • 2/5.

    I did not enjoy the episode. It was messy, and not directed well.

    It still gets two points for being Walking Dead, and having a good ending.
  • edited May 2014
    5/5 for me simply because it was intense and had me yelling at my screen a couple of times. Much better than episode 2.

    If i start nit picking things like the length, the writing and other things that i won't mention to avoid spoilers then i would probably rate it something like 3.5/5

    The 5/5 rating is only temporary because i'm a dumb fanboy and it will stay in my head for a couple of days then after a while i'll see the episode as a 3.5/5
  • Exactly my thoughts.

    An honest 2/5 from me.
    butthead posted: »

    2/5. I did not enjoy the episode. It was messy, and not directed well. It still gets two points for being Walking Dead, and having a good ending.

  • edited May 2014
    I give it a 4.5/5

    I'm sorry but Reggie's voice acting... it was a bit cringe-worthy, I have nothing against the character or the guy who was doing the voice acting itself, but the character and the voice don't really fit...

    Other than that I quite enjoyed it, besides a few of the characters model movements that were a bit... awkward... but I ignored some of the awkward placements quite easily.
  • Its kinda 4. It was a good episode. Not as intense as 2 but good.
  • In comparison to the other Telltale episodes, I'd rate this one a weak 3 out of 5. For me it was just... not that special. Also it felt even shorter than the other recent Telltale episodes, which were ALREADY pretty damn short. Honestly, I barely spent over an hour on this one. There just wasn't much content. But it isn't length alone. Maybe it's just me, but this episode didn't emotionally move me. The new characters were either not interesting, or not fleshed out properly and I'm having a hard time getting attached to any of the old ones. Not like in Season 1's early episodes. I don't know, in comparison to the brilliant third episode of the Wolf Among Us, something just felt lacking here.
  • (still haven't played the episode, waiting for it on steam) I saw the up at noon with Reggie's voice actor, it really wasn't that good. :P
    _Juice_Box_ posted: »

    I give it a 4.5/5 I'm sorry but Reggie's voice acting... it was a bit cringe-worthy, I have nothing against the character or

  • I don't agree but you can have your opinion. No, i'm not saying it was a flawless episode but it was at least a 3/5 or 3.5/5 for me.
    butthead posted: »

    2/5. I did not enjoy the episode. It was messy, and not directed well. It still gets two points for being Walking Dead, and having a good ending.

  • AmazingAura01AmazingAura01 Banned
    edited May 2014
    4.8/5. I didn't like Reggie's voice acting. Seriously, it was pretty damn fake-ish.
  • CripsCrips Banned
    To be honest, A House Divided was better, but this episode is not bad either! I loved it actually.

    Oh, um, 4 outta 5
  • edited May 2014
    Very good episode, but again too short. I thought it will be at least 2,5 hours long and again I'm disappointed. Also Telltale wasted potential of 400 days characters, besides of Bonnie. I wouldn't tell the difference if they weren't in the game.
  • It's not shorter than Vince's story, the fuck you talking about?
    Jodie posted: »

    0,0000000000000000001/5. Really!?? Shorter than Vince story and the most annoying ending I have ever seen??!!!!

  • 2/5. I'm disappointed first time with Telltale's TWD.
Sign in to comment in this discussion.