I would say Season 1's choices is far more better than Season 2.
I am sure I am going to get downvotes... ok let's cut to the chase. It's not what I am going to say that Season 2 sucks or Season 1 is way too good. First, Let's just analyse the choices:
First, let's take a good look on S1E1 choices, we had to choose either to save Doug or Carley, there are good reasons to save them both but unfortunately only one will live and one will die. One hell of a tough choice, but still, I like it.
There's a choice when either you have to kill the dog or leave him in All That Remains, most of the players kill the dog to end his suffering. I getting for downvote.. -.- This choice isn't very nice, I mean, how can I say this is a touch choice?
Saving Ben or not, this one is good also! Choosing to sit with Luke or Kenny is also a tough choice. Both seasons' storyline are nice, but choices..
Season 2 disappointed not exactly.
I don't give a fuck even if I get millions of downvotes, just sharing my opinion, I don't think Season 2 has a lot of tough choices.