Who do you REALLY think is the REAL killer?

DanalizaDanaliza Banned
edited June 2014 in The Wolf Among Us

Hi everyone, I know there are other threads like that, but I dont care. I just want your theories and about who you really think the killer is. Im just so into this game, everyone is as I believe. But I want your theories, I want you to share them with them. I dont really have a theory, thats why I want yours, each one of you is probably smart than one another. Maybe Bigby is who you may think the killer is? Just anyone you think is the killer (not saying bigby is who i think is the killer) I just saw the ginger guy everywhere, though Im still not sure. Also tell me what you want to see in the finale, and what do you think is gonna happen to Nerissa ? Because we all watched the finale's trailer, and I think she's going to let Bigby take the ribbon off. But what do you say? What do you think? Share below please. Thanks!
And dont forget to check out my fan fiction of BigbyxReader on wattpad, its called Die For Wolf's Love
Thanks!

«1

Comments

  • CM probably hired someone.

    My guess is "The Caller" from Beauty and Beast's voicemail.

  • edited June 2014

    This is my theory but...I think Vivian because of this. When you go to the Butcher first, the chalkboard has all kinds of names, with various letters and numbers. You look to the bottom, her name is there, which makes me believe she is glamoured. Georgie is up there, due to the spell around the ribbons. I think the 'caller' is Vivian-we don't know WHO she really is or her Fable. When Bigby entered the room, she got up REAL quick and stood beside the CM.

    I know the teasers change but when everyone was backing up into the corner, made me wonder what was REALLY going down. Maybe it was her, maybe it was Bigby. :) I still think she has a much bigger part, then just being 'Georgie's girl.'

  • I think Vivian is the killer.

  • I think Vivian is the killer as well. Has the means, we just don't know the motive yet.

  • Fuck u telltale! I will not change my mind in believing "who's the killer" even if u change the script. I'm sure since episode 1 that t's the red haired guy!

  • I'm pretty sure it never was, but ok...

    Xemnes posted: »

    Fuck u telltale! I will not change my mind in believing "who's the killer" even if u change the script. I'm sure since episode 1 that t's the red haired guy!

  • I do. Would explained why the wait from ep 1 - 2 was like 4 month

    papai46 posted: »

    I'm pretty sure it never was, but ok...

  • The Caller? You mean Jersey?

    CM probably hired someone. My guess is "The Caller" from Beauty and Beast's voicemail.

  • Yeah, at this point, Vivian's the only character who actually could be the murderer without it being mega obvious or disappointing. Well, her or Tiny Tim since they've both been on the side for a long while.

    pudding_pie posted: »

    This is my theory but...I think Vivian because of this. When you go to the Butcher first, the chalkboard has all kinds of names, w

  • Vivian still has a ribbon on, and say ''these lips are sealed'' when entering the strip club in EP2. She's involved, but not killer imo

  • Having a ribbon doesn't mean she can't kill people. Plus, the ribbon might be fake, because I'm sure she could convince the Crooked Man to remove it if she wanted.

    Vivian still has a ribbon on, and say ''these lips are sealed'' when entering the strip club in EP2. She's involved, but not killer imo

  • No she says "My lips are sealed" which isn't what the spell is. Everyone else says "these lips are sealed"

    Vivian still has a ribbon on, and say ''these lips are sealed'' when entering the strip club in EP2. She's involved, but not killer imo

  • I think the Red-Headed Guy might have been a..... red-herring. :D

    papai46 posted: »

    I'm pretty sure it never was, but ok...

  • Blind SniperBlind Sniper Moderator
    edited June 2014

    It's obviously Bukfin. Behind that fuzzy, green, incompetent exterior lies a cold blooded killer whose mercilessness is only rivaled by the equally ruthless likes of Bluebeard, the Crooked Man, or Jersey Devil.

    All those times Bigby told Bufkin to "fuck off" had finally taken their toll and made him snap.

  • That's not Jersey. The text colour is slightly different and "The Caller" sounds nothing like Jersey.

    That1Guy posted: »

    The Caller? You mean Jersey?

  • I heard somewhere it was because the mundy police originally played a big part in the story, but some people at Telltale didn't found that faithful to the comics, so they had rewrite the entire plot.

    Xemnes posted: »

    I do. Would explained why the wait from ep 1 - 2 was like 4 month

  • Your passionate insistence on having us talk and not having anything to contribute yourself, including but not limited to: lack of attempt at posing arguments; conversation pieces; and points for debate, leave nothing but "check out my fan fiction", black and white and clear as day.

  • Oh shit, I take that back! I hadn't payed attention apparently and only remembered that the Caller and Jersey had similar text colours! But wow, ok, that's another suspect.

    Golthar posted: »

    That's not Jersey. The text colour is slightly different and "The Caller" sounds nothing like Jersey.

  • Vivian is "Georgie's favorite", and still have to use the ribbon.

    Two things that scape attention of most people I see is that:
    1) The ribbon magic doesn't work in other people using the ribbon, hence Faith could be told of Lily's appointment with Woody. Meaning that Vivian is free to talk to them.

    2) The only person in the entire game so far that matches the blue fabric, is prone to invade and sneak into places, and do whatever to get cash is Jack. I wouldn't be surprised if he delivered the heads Vivian provided him to Crane's steps, without asking questions.

    Another thing that bothers me, but I have nothing to back up is that people assume Vivian isn't glamoured, when she could be not even human, and we haven't the slightest idea of her fable, which could be related to the laughing person in Lily's body dump. Someone only she can hear?

    Vivian might want to start a war between The Crooked Man and Bluebeard, and Jack see an opportunity in removing such powerful and controlling fable as TCM. So he dump heads in Crane's doorstep as her request, and she strain the relations between Crane and Crooked, with the pictures and killing.

    BTW, the girl on the picture could be anyone. Even herself, instead of Lily. Crane mention the massage appointment is with VIVIAN, meaning that she could be not only the pimp, but the hooker herself, and Faith had to cover for her, because she wasn't Crane's regular too.

    Another point of interest with less significance: Beauty saw Snow, something Crane's usual hooker could be aware of not doing.

    One more less significant point is that Nerissa say she have NO FRIENDS LEFT, meaning that even using the ribbon, Vivian isn't considered "one of the girls", backed up with Lily's picture that have only Faith and Nerissa with her.

  • dojo32161dojo32161 Moderator

    Someone in the Pudding n' Pie. If you smash the cigarette machine, Bigby's brand of smoke comes out. Everyone goes out of there way to tell him that it's a terrible brand, while in room 207, the room had a Huff N' Puff in there, which leads to the suggestion that the killer smokes the same brand. So why would the company put their brand of cigarettes in a strip joints club unless they were guaranteed to get money? Which leads me to believe that either Georgie, Hans, Vivian or Nerissa is the killer.

  • edited June 2014

    Clever Hans? No way. He doesn't have ANYTHING to do with the crimes. He probably doesn't even know who the Crooked Man is. Come on, it's CLEVER HANS we are talking about. Woody looks like the Puss in Boots near him.

    dojo32161 posted: »

    Someone in the Pudding n' Pie. If you smash the cigarette machine, Bigby's brand of smoke comes out. Everyone goes out of there wa

  • dojo32161dojo32161 Moderator
    edited June 2014

    It could have been an accident. I mean his fairy tale involves him confusing instructions and gouging the eyes out of his livestock.

    OptimusJ posted: »

    Clever Hans? No way. He doesn't have ANYTHING to do with the crimes. He probably doesn't even know who the Crooked Man is. Come on, it's CLEVER HANS we are talking about. Woody looks like the Puss in Boots near him.

  • JonesJJonesJ Banned

    Yeah, I agree with you on that, pie. Think she is glamoured as well. Believe she used Georgie and the pudding & pie as her 'stomping grounds' to help the CM out; he was just a pawn in their devious schemes. Her name on the chalkboard gave it away. Why else would she be there?

    There was a huff n' puff in room 207; no one but Bigby smokes that 'cheap and god awful brand.' The pudding & pie had a cigarette machine there that had those and the Shontelle in stock. Georgie, Hans, Vivia and the dancers have access to these.

    Think she is Georgie's 'favorite' because he KNOWS who she is; he may have knowledge of her and what she is capable of. The CM maybe using her AND Mary for his own purpose.

    pudding_pie posted: »

    This is my theory but...I think Vivian because of this. When you go to the Butcher first, the chalkboard has all kinds of names, w

  • The Caller is voiced by Julian Kwasneski. I forgot who voices Jersey.

    That1Guy posted: »

    Oh shit, I take that back! I hadn't payed attention apparently and only remembered that the Caller and Jersey had similar text colours! But wow, ok, that's another suspect.

  • So, sneaking at Woodlands and leaving not only ONE but TWO heads fits in "accidental killing" how?
    If Hans had any doing in that, Georgie would produce a fake knife and would gladly give Hans to Crane.

    dojo32161 posted: »

    It could have been an accident. I mean his fairy tale involves him confusing instructions and gouging the eyes out of his livestock.

  • dojo32161dojo32161 Moderator

    Hans really isn't my first suspect anyway, Vivian on the other hand is much more mysterious.

    OptimusJ posted: »

    So, sneaking at Woodlands and leaving not only ONE but TWO heads fits in "accidental killing" how? If Hans had any doing in that, Georgie would produce a fake knife and would gladly give Hans to Crane.

  • It was never implied that Viv was Crane's pro. Crane asked Snow to change his appointment by calling Viv, who is the hostess.

    OptimusJ posted: »

    Vivian is "Georgie's favorite", and still have to use the ribbon. Two things that scape attention of most people I see is that:

  • I still don't think CM had anything to do with the murders. Whether it was done by an underling without CM's permission is a possibility.

  • Nerissa also says 'my lips are sealed' in episode 3 when Crane shows up. It's the same thing

    No she says "My lips are sealed" which isn't what the spell is. Everyone else says "these lips are sealed"

  • Actually... Doesn't Vivian smoke Huff n Puffs?? Like, I thought we'd actually seen it, or had proof of it. I mean, people used to say that like it was a fact. If it is true that she for sure smokes them, then she's even more suspicious.

    JonesJ posted: »

    Yeah, I agree with you on that, pie. Think she is glamoured as well. Believe she used Georgie and the pudding & pie as her 'st

  • Toad junior

  • I'm sure Faith says it during the scuffle with Woody.

    No she says "My lips are sealed" which isn't what the spell is. Everyone else says "these lips are sealed"

  • Vivian makes sense. The only motive I can think of is switching appointments for both of them being killed and its possible they both setup Crane, which may have compromised TCM's operations and being the top girl in the Puddin' and Pie, she probably figured it out.

    pcharl01 posted: »

    I still don't think CM had anything to do with the murders. Whether it was done by an underling without CM's permission is a possibility.

  • I think Vivian is a little too obvious. I've heard some pretty interesting theories about Gren and Toad.

  • http://www.telltalegames.com/community/discussion/comment/1331076

    The red-haired guy's name is Cryer. As you can see from this thread I made, he can't be the killer.

    Xemnes posted: »

    Fuck u telltale! I will not change my mind in believing "who's the killer" even if u change the script. I'm sure since episode 1 that t's the red haired guy!

  • I think it's Bluebeard, he sounds quite similar

    The Caller is voiced by Julian Kwasneski. I forgot who voices Jersey.

  • we do. Faith wanted to leave, maybe Vivian didn't want to let her go... and Lily... Lily and Faith were friends so maybe she just knew too much...

    Grafite posted: »

    I think Vivian is the killer as well. Has the means, we just don't know the motive yet.

  • JonesJJonesJ Banned

    Watch it has been Hans the entire time. He DID mess up his engagement in his Fable.

  • Bluebeard, But I'm not really sure. The element of surprise lies on that particular spot of the plot. I'm awaiting to be surprised by telltale.

  • VIVIAN! OMG!

    Alt text

Sign in to comment in this discussion.