Clem vs Ellie

13567

Comments

  • Not at all. I wanted to throttle her.

    Am I the only one who found Ellie annoying? braces for dislikes

  • "Who do you prefer" Ellie could probably take down Rambo, the game lacks realism.

    Chase4902 posted: »

    this is stupid why do this look i love clem but in reality u guys know ellie would win she knows more and she older but for real this is stupid and im ready to be downvoted

  • I think Ellie is a better character than Clem. Clem is a great character too, but I just feel that Ellie was developed better. Ellie is also a much stronger survivor

  • Strange, I actually prefer Joel to Ellie. Maybe aggressive isn't the word for it, but angry is. She can be very angry at other people for the littlest of things, which to me is a less desirable trait to have. Of course, she is a realistic fourteen-year old, from what I've seen.

    As for swearing, to me it's a small bit off-putting in media when one of the main characters is swearing nearly every other sentence. Also, I personally would prefer to grow up in the apocalypse, rather then live a life of luxury and then be suddenly thrown into a pile of shit. And where did the comments about Season 2 even come from? I never said anything about The Walking Dead being better than the Last of Us, all I said was I liked Clementine more than Ellie.

    Please remember that around this time the whole LGBT thing was very popular. I'm not a homophobic, but Ellie being a lesbian was definitely shoehorned in just so Naughty Dog could have a better reputation with the masses. The story would not have been any worse nor better if they had gotten rid of the whole lesbian thing. Have you ever had a best friend? I assume you have. You would do nearly anything for that person, correct? They are basically your brother/sister. Riley and Ellie were perfectly fine as best friends. They worked well, they had good chemistry. But then at the very end, some completely throwaway kiss comes in and it's just...there. It didn't add anything to Ellie's character at all.

    And the only thing I bashed the DLC on was the "eh" DLC Left Behind. I never bashed on it anywhere else, I simply stated that I preferred Clementine to Ellie.

    Team_Purple posted: »

    I wouldn't call her aggressive. Joel: definitely, but I think that Ellie is more complex and has more reason to be 'aggressive' if

  • edited August 2014

    I love both, but i'd say ellie. But clem's certainly sweeter then her haha.

    Edit: apparently i said something wrong

  • edited August 2014

    I vote Ben because why not.

  • Off topic, but the dislike button has got to go... You get down voted for simply stating your opinion

  • Thats the point of the dislike button, I think.

    Off topic, but the dislike button has got to go... You get down voted for simply stating your opinion

  • Are you being sarcastic?

    RomanZombie posted: »

    Thats the point of the dislike button, I think.

  • Yup I'm changing my stance, I vote Ben as well.

    BenUseful posted: »

    I vote Ben because why not.

  • The alternative is they start a huge fight over your opinion.

    Off topic, but the dislike button has got to go... You get down voted for simply stating your opinion

  • ... no

    Are you being sarcastic?

  • edited August 2014

    Oh alright, my bad

    RomanZombie posted: »

    ... no

  • Sometimes both

    The alternative is they start a huge fight over your opinion.

  • CIementine CIementine Banned
    edited August 2014

    Alt text

    Green613 posted: »

    Clem easily.

  • "anyone who's played it would agree with me." Iv'e played it and I couldn't agree less ;) And I must say, I didn't notice much character development with her amazing script of "Fuck bitch motherfucking shit dick ass".

    .

  • Is that even a question???? Clem would win by 100000000000%!!!!!

  • clem is life, way better than whiney ellie. joel is boring. lee is love

  • I'm sick of this. You know why I didn't like the last of us at first? Because everytime I looked at twd on YouTube, on devianatart, wherever, there were some tlou fans spamming "the last of us is better." "Ellie and Joel are better." "Yo, if you like this, go check of tlou. Soooo much better, you'll thank me, I swear :3"

    I got annoyed. It made me hate the last of us. Like any natural fan, I clicked into the last of us and just started thinking to myself "the last of us is shit." I'm different now though, I think that both are great games with great characters. Threads like these are pointless and just start fights against people who can't stand other people's opinions. What do we get out of voting which one's better anyway? Just accept that they're both good characters.

  • IamClementine

    Clementine all that way.

  • I really do like Ellie, unlike the majority on this forum it seems, but Clem just is so much more likeable and more developed.

  • How is Ellie annoying?

    Am I the only one who found Ellie annoying? braces for dislikes

  • Agreed

    I think Ellie is a better character than Clem. Clem is a great character too, but I just feel that Ellie was developed better. Ellie is also a much stronger survivor

  • Remember when they saw the ice cream truck? Or when she read that diary in the house?

    Team_Purple posted: »

    I think it's different because Ellie was born into the apocalypse, while Clem wasn't. It's a bit sadder because Ellie doesn't know

  • Like most of the people on here you're a fanboy

    Ellias posted: »

    clem is life, way better than whiney ellie. joel is boring. lee is love

  • I liked Season 1 Clem more than Ellie, but thus far, cumulatively, I prefer Ellie. Other than a few scenes, like when Kenny was reintroduced, she has felt completely neutral and emotionless. She reminds me of Carl from season 3 of the show.

  • I love how no one gets that, lol.

    RomanZombie posted: »

    Thats the point of the dislike button, I think.

  • I don't know just to see what other people think?

    Tenmile posted: »

    I'm sick of this. You know why I didn't like the last of us at first? Because everytime I looked at twd on YouTube, on devianatart

  • I'm biased on this subject, so I'll put it like this...

    Ellie 8/10

    Clementine 9.5/10

  • clem,clem and uh clem. oh yeah and clem.

  • edited August 2014

    Insane amounts of unnecessary swearing, getting in the way, ruining immersion when no one notices her, never shutting the hell up for 1 second, etc.

    Edit: Almost forgot! That fucking joke book!

    xWally posted: »

    How is Ellie annoying?

  • AHHHH CAN'T DECIDE!! Can't I love them both equally?!
    Alt text

  • The greatest videogame of all time is Megaman 3

  • edited August 2014

    I mean, both character are loveable and reasonable, for me at least. But both know how to survive in a world where you need to fight. They also seen Some brutal things. Like for example, Clem lost Lee and her parents while Ellie lost her parents and her girlfriend, Riley. So we got that down, now let see where their strength and weakness lies. With Clem, she is able to manipulate people to help her. She is small, so she can sneak around more a lot easier and with ease. She also seems to know how to use melee weapons effectively. Plus, she can be show to be ruthless at times, if that the way you play her that is. She can also be seen using her surroundings to her benefit, But her weaknesses are that she can easily be man handled demonstrated by Troy. She also is unable to use weapons that have a bit of a kick to them,, relying a smaller guns like pistols. Now to Ellie's strong points, one of them being, she is able to use rifles and other types of guns that may have a kick to them. Obviously stronger than Clem, she can easily man handled her if given the opportunity. She also have been shown to have been able to kill bandits with little trouble. Also, she is immune to the fungus disease which caused the apocalypse, in Ellie's story, so let just assume that she is immune to walker bites. She is able to craft as well, so when she is injured or need a weapon, she can easily craft that. But here is her problem, she can be too trustworthy when it comes to kids around or younger than her age. She too can be man handled, so if a walker shows up, she can be killed easily. It also doesn't help that she needs supplies to craft stuff and in apocalypse, that's rare. So here who will win.... is probably equally, it just depends on where they do it. If Clem fought Ellie where they were no supplies and walkers near by, then she tries kill her by tricking her though Ellie may notice it and they both her into fight. Of course Clem will try to attack her with the hatchet, it does not work and Ellie grabs it away from her. Ellie then tries to shoot her but with no success. This alerts the walkers who comes towards them. Ellie then quickly tries to craft what she has left and makes a smoke bomb. She then proceeds to throw it, causing Clem to be stunned. But when Ellie gets to the cloud of smoke, Clem have already gotten away. Clem would have capped her legs and sneak away from the chaos, leaving Ellie in the hands of walkers. Now it is a different story if the fight is near no walkers and have supplies. Ellie then would be able to craft a grenade or a Molotov and throw it to Clem. She will then be hit by either one and stunned long enough to die. So yeah, but if I pick which one I'll put my money on, it'll be Clem, seeing how supplies are rare and there are walkers around every corner.

  • They're both pretty cool but Minsc is cooler
    Alt text

  • Ellie is so much better than Clementine

    Alt text

  • Yes! The Ranch part is probably one of my favorite scenes of the game. "Is this really all they had to worry about?" It's so trivial and beautiful.

    Remember when they saw the ice cream truck? Or when she read that diary in the house?

  • Yep, how I felt every time I've made Clem upset. I just, just can't stop feeling bad if Clem feels bad. But yeah, I think Ellie and Clem are equally good characters. Just season 2 been a little rough with character development lately, but hopefully episode 5 can fix that.

    Ellie is so much better than Clementine

  • well tell me what website youre on? also you too.

    xWally posted: »

    Like most of the people on here you're a fanboy

Sign in to comment in this discussion.