Lee vs Carver who would in a fight?

edited September 2014 in The Walking Dead

I think Lee would win, there was never a time where Carver showed his strength in a fair fight and Lee has proven he's a good brawler. What do you think?(I might be unfair too because I love Lee so much #NeverForgetLee)

«13

Comments

  • I would photoshop something but too lazy :( Lee by a longshot

  • Would depend on whether or not Carver was holding Clementine hostage

  • Lee. The whole reason Carver is dangerous is because he is powerful not strong. Lee is younger, stronger, and more capable, despite not having the same power complex.

  • Depends who's controlling Lee.

    Any Lee who gave Molly a good arse-whooping could probably take Carver.

  • That was the hardest fucking QTE in the whole game...my god I had to try that over and over to get it.

    Depends who's controlling Lee. Any Lee who gave Molly a good arse-whooping could probably take Carver.

  • I remember that, all of my friends except me weren't able to get it EVER.

    Depends who's controlling Lee. Any Lee who gave Molly a good arse-whooping could probably take Carver.

  • edited August 2014

    I found it was significantly easier on PC with a mouse than any other platform, because of how much quicker you could move the cursor.

    Got my arse kicked on iOS and 360.

    bloop posted: »

    I remember that, all of my friends except me weren't able to get it EVER.

  • I got my ass kicked the first time, but I went back and punched the shit out of her.

    I found it was significantly easier on PC with a mouse than any other platform, because of how much quicker you could move the cursor. Got my arse kicked on iOS and 360.

  • While Carver was busy slapping children, hitting people with talkie-walkies, torturing people strapped to chair. Lee was being Lee (+Power-Up of Urban, Power of the Pimp-Hand).

  • Not sure actually. While we've never seen Carver in a fair fight, he's clearly a fearless brutal and tough man. Getting shot in the shoulder with a rifle and getting back up like it was nothing shows he is probably a very capable fighter.

    On the other hand, Lee is also pretty fearless, resourceful, pretty strong and a skilled fighter and shooter(he hardly ever misses his shots and at best can win 100% of his fights in season 1).

    I would give it to Lee because, despite it being determinant, he can go toe to toe with Molly when she gets the drop on him and has a weapon over him and STILL win, and he can beat Kenny when Kenny is extremely pissed off, both of which are very noteworthy feats.

  • Well, Carver actually seems pretty strong from what we know about him. Getting shot in the shoulder with a rifle and getting back up like nothing happened isn't easy. Despite that, I still think Lee would win. He can take quite a lot more punishment in episode 5 of season 1 than just one gunshot and still get back up. xD

    Team_Purple posted: »

    Lee. The whole reason Carver is dangerous is because he is powerful not strong. Lee is younger, stronger, and more capable, despite not having the same power complex.

  • Lee can get shot in the gut and still kill The Stranger with one arm, I'd say Lee can take more.

    Well, Carver actually seems pretty strong from what we know about him. Getting shot in the shoulder with a rifle and getting back

  • Carver, i suck at QTEs

  • Well, my Lee won most of the fight scene QTEs.

    Carver, i suck at QTEs

  • Depends who's controlling Lee. Any Lee who gave Molly a good arse-whooping could probably take Carver.

  • edited August 2014

    Lee FTW! Lee would fucking end him! My Lee kicked Molly's ass, he can handle Carver!

  • You should model swap Bigby, The Woodsman, and Faith in Episode 1 of The Wolf Among Us with

    Bigby=Lee

    The Woodsman=Carver

    Faith=?

    I would photoshop something but too lazy Lee by a longshot

  • Angry Lee

  • Faith=Clem :D

    bloop posted: »

    You should model swap Bigby, The Woodsman, and Faith in Episode 1 of The Wolf Among Us with Bigby=Lee The Woodsman=Carver Faith=?

  • I don't want to see poor Clem get smacked by Carver, how about Carley?

    Faith=Clem

  • Clem would make more sense. Carver actually hit her in the game, so Lee comes back and has something to say about it. Besides, Faith was about a foot taller than Clem. It's likely the slap will go right over her head.

    bloop posted: »

    I don't want to see poor Clem get smacked by Carver, how about Carley?

  • Whoa. That was so badass.

    bloop posted: »

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JyP3jxxoiwY

  • Yeah I guess, but I start thinking about what happened after the fight, since Faith gets all flirty with Bigby.

    Clem would make more sense. Carver actually hit her in the game, so Lee comes back and has something to say about it. Besides, Faith was about a foot taller than Clem. It's likely the slap will go right over her head.

  • Lee would wreck his butt.

  • NeverForget

    icrieverytiem

    TakeUsBack

    Twistee posted: »

    LEE!

  • Lee probably

  • I remember once hearing lee was just a regular guy, average height 5'9-10ish in he's 30s.
    But he doesn't seem like a regular guy to me.

  • Carver slapped Clem (determinant)

    If I'm playing as Lee, Troy and Carver are both dead.

  • Lee would freaking clobber the shit out of Carver! Lee doesn't need some walkie talkie. He gots his fists! GO LEE!

  • edited August 2014

    Carver's just a weird old man who barks more then bites. Lee would probably win.

  • My god, everyone says Lee.

  • I would think in a 1 on 1 fight Carver would win, not because of strenght but because he would do anything to win ~ that includes fighting dirty.
    However, if Clementine was the reason for the fight (such as rescueing her from Carver) then I would say Lee would win the fight ~ different mentality

  • Lee would have because he was the main character, that gives him checkpoint immunity.

  • Well, looked what happened in Episode 5.

    NeverForget

    icrieverytiem

    TakeUsBack

    TheFeels

    IMissLee

    Jayroen posted: »

    Lee would have because he was the main character, that gives him checkpoint immunity.

  • I think Lee would win. Carvers only asset is numbers.

Sign in to comment in this discussion.