Would You Kill Arvo If You Could?

13468912

Comments

  • If his sister really is sick, she wouldn't be healthy enough to be at the shootout so if she exists then she probably is in the woods.

    Kennysucks posted: »

    I know, and how do we know he doesn't have a sick sister in the woods? he seems pretty truthful, he told Clem and Jane about his group and where they were located, and to be fair, Jane did steal his gun.

  • You Can Tell When A Person Is Lying, He Just Seamed To Be Shaking A Lot And Looking Away.

    If his sister really is sick, she wouldn't be healthy enough to be at the shootout so if she exists then she probably is in the woods.

  • carver?

    prink34320 posted: »

    If I was forced to kill someone, I'd choose myself.

  • In Games Your Not Really Yourself, You Tend To Be More Violent.

    You say that but I doubt it, thats one problem with this all being a game. I think most do gooders likely wouldnt do what they think.

  • He had no say in his group's attempt to rob Clem's group. He tells you as much. Besides, you think HE is in any position to resist them? The skinhead would have beat the stuffing out of him if he said no.

    lightmyfire posted: »

    But him leading his group to ours is as bad as 'peaceful revenge' because really, in an ambush involving guns and being robbed wha

  • He Dies Either Way, While Kill Others While You Die? If He Said No He Would Be Beaten To Death (Literally), But Nobody In Our Group Dies. He Says Yes He Dies In The Shootout.

    Bokor posted: »

    He had no say in his group's attempt to rob Clem's group. He tells you as much. Besides, you think HE is in any position to resist them? The skinhead would have beat the stuffing out of him if he said no.

  • I Vote Interrogation!

    Yo-da-Man posted: »

    Kill him I won't. But have Clementine interrogate him Batman style I would.

  • Forum, Thread, Same Thing.

    Puncake32 posted: »

    Thread*

  • Hey, a lot of people who were okay with robbing him also wanted to murder him. That is unabashed evil, especially in a lawless society where robbery is far more serious than it is to us.

    Bloodeon posted: »

    He Dies Either Way, While Kill Others While You Die? If He Said No He Would Be Beaten To Death (Literally), But Nobody In Our Group Dies. He Says Yes He Dies In The Shootout.

  • Meh. He's kinda cute

  • edited August 2014

    I am true to my word, I would sacrifice myself, I would force myself to do so.

    You say that but I doubt it, thats one problem with this all being a game. I think most do gooders likely wouldnt do what they think.

  • I just can't kill sorry... I mean Walkers is one things, but someone whose living... I just couldn't live with myself...

    Ascari posted: »

    carver?

  • "In this life now, you either kill or you die... Or you die and you kill."

  • Did You Kill Duck For Kenny, Or Make Kenny Do It?

    prink34320 posted: »

    I just can't kill sorry... I mean Walkers is one things, but someone whose living... I just couldn't live with myself...

  • "It's Kill Or Be Killed"

    "In this life now, you either kill or you die... Or you die and you kill."

  • We Could Interrogate Him, And If He's Lying We Could Kill Him Yes?

    To be honest, I'm not sure what i'd do, it is true that he is suspicious of hiding medicine and that he set up an ambush, but we b

  • No. Unless something else happens in episode 5 that provokes me to kill him.

  • If anybody dies in the shootout (which is 100% likely) I will probably
    murder Arvo, assuming he survived. In my playthrough, I did not steal
    from him and now he's gonna get the people I love killed! Screw him!

  • Well, there's a difference between someone whose dead already and someone whose truly still alive.

    Bloodeon posted: »

    Did You Kill Duck For Kenny, Or Make Kenny Do It?

  • After Arvo found out they had a baby, he was telling his group to stop and don't shoot.

  • I'll need to borrow the crowbar

  • True, But He Still Was Conscious. So Did You?

    prink34320 posted: »

    Well, there's a difference between someone whose dead already and someone whose truly still alive.

  • Want A Saltlick Also?

    I'll need to borrow the crowbar

  • Why? What's the point? I don't think I'm gonna be tempted to kill a disabled guy anytime soon. o_e

  • edited August 2014

    I think so I mean I didn't even steal his supplies and still he wants to rob us
    he led his crazy russian friends to us
    so if the option is given Arvo will die

  • Hmmm maybe idk with all the shit going on am at the point of just saying fuck it to make my life easier. Arvo seem nice but like many he will do whatever is needed to live. Am sketchy and he seems smart in terms of manipulating or tricking someone. Only time will tell, time as in Tuesday morning when the ep comes out.

  • Only if you think it will help

    Bloodeon posted: »

    Want A Saltlick Also?

  • edited August 2014

    If you don't steal the medicine from Arvo, I think the reason he comes back is mostly Jane's fault. She was too aggressive and stole his gun. I mean, I can see why Jane did these things, she said herself threatening him was so Arvo wouldn't come back later on and obviously by giving back the gun he may shoot them both. It makes sense for her to do both of those things but at the same time Arvo probably thought that Clementine's group was full of crazy bandits and maybe that played a part in why he came back to rob them.

    He did lead his people to Clementine, but it was probably because the bald guy wanted him to do it. It is obvious that Arvo isn't the leader of their group, still doesn't excuse his part in the attempted robbery though. He did try and stop them when he realized the group had a baby, which makes it clear he isn't a complete psycho. (If his reluctance to shoot Clementine earlier wasn't enough proof.) I'm hoping there isn't a choice to kill him at all, I'm thinking that if the rest of his group dies, Clementine and whoever is left of her group will be in a dire situation (As they were before Arvo showed up at all.) and he will help them. If he feels guilty enough or is threatened. For example, if he was begging for his life and said that he had supplies to help them back at his camp or whatever and they need his help to find it and would die otherwise so they'd come with him. I hope that happens instead of a kill/spare choice but we'll see.

    Basically if there is the choice to kill him, I'm not going to do it. Because he is an interesting character to me and I want him alive as long as possible, even though there's a snowball's chance in hell of him making it to season 3.

  • MyClementine does NOT kill, only if she is going to be killed otherwise. She's just a girl, remember?

    Alt text

  • That's Why I Said IF.

    nodenaatti posted: »

    MyClementine does NOT kill, only if she is going to be killed otherwise. She's just a girl, remember?

  • Yeah, at least don't kill him until we know if he has a sister at all.

    If you don't steal the medicine from Arvo, I think the reason he comes back is mostly Jane's fault. She was too aggressive and sto

  • Today Then?

    Hyena4010 posted: »

    Hmmm maybe idk with all the shit going on am at the point of just saying fuck it to make my life easier. Arvo seem nice but like m

  • Or At Least Interrogation.

    Journey95 posted: »

    I think so I mean I didn't even steal his supplies and still he wants to rob us he led his crazy russian friends to us so if the option is given Arvo will die

  • Yes It Will.

    Only if you think it will help

  • Yup I kill him, I aint got time for this shit

    Bloodeon posted: »

    Today Then?

  • edited August 2014

    After Episode 5: YES! He just shot Clem without a reason, even if you sided with him the whole episode. For his sake, I hope my Clementine doesn't see him again.

Sign in to comment in this discussion.