User Avatar Image

[SPOILERS] CARLEY [Ep 3 discussion]

posted by Oblivion1659 on - last edited - Viewed by 22.1K users
Hey i am really annoyed about carley being shot when it happend i didnt even want to carry on playing anyway maybe they could bring carly back she could have just been grazed by the bullet.No one even checked to she if she was dead the group could meet up with her again.I wont be buying anymore episodes unless carly comes back my friends also said the same.

Please say in the comments that you want carly back and make a thread about this and then maybe telltale games will see that we want carly back.
558 Comments - Linear Discussion: Classic Style
  • divisionten;658165 said:
    Carley/Doug WILL die.
    I was actually pretty surprised they kept Doug alive in Episode 2 but I predicted they will fall in Ep2 or Ep3 so I was right. They have to to reduce the workload for the episodes basically.
  • I was crushed when Carly got shot. Normally i try playing through each episode straight through before going back and doing things differently. I actually closed the game cause i couldn't go any further(was able to go back in after getting a drink and cooling off).

    So glad i was able to leave Lilly on the side of the road like that, clearly she wasn't leadership material and lost her head. Still wish there was some way to save Carly, or even Duck(annoying as that little brat was...).
  • TTG managed to turn my eyes into waterfalls. I'm just happy that she got a quick, painless exit, I was expecting much worse for her.
  • Dunno, I expected Doug/Carly to die. Actually expected them to get killed off in episode 2 or something so I was surprised there (but Doug/Carly barely had any screen time in episode 2 so it doesn't really count).

    From a technical stand point... I mean I'm sure just about everybody saw it coming because it would be more difficult story wise to keep them alive. Only thing that irks me is that the save Doug/Carly event was about the only thing that players have actually had control over that really impacted the story (pretty much every other choice either adds/subtracts to invisible statistics that get pulled during conversations or the choices actually turn out to be... well, not choices as is the case here).

    So chalk one death up to a massive cop out and everybody's pretty much playing the same story now. It's kind of pointless to give a choice and then just erase all the answers later.
  • Same... Carleys death felt forced to me... and she was my fav character.... i DESPERATELY want them to patch her back in. It can be done....
  • I didnt knew that when on Talking Dead Episode 5.When he asked a question from Patrick If there will a romance budding between Lee and Carley and he said theres hints etc.I srsly didnt Knew that they would kill her :(
  • A friend told me their friend was able to get Lilly to shoot Ben instead of Carley in the roadside confrontation... But we all know how reliable that sounds. Has anyone managed to do this by accusing Ben?
  • Carley's death was sort of shocking in how it was performed but I knew it was coming, because I just knew what the writers were going for.

    I think TTG is going too far with this whole dark storyline thing. They're trying to make the game depressing and hard core to the max but I think this is trying too hard. There's not a single positive thing in the game anymore. That might do it for some but this just screams "We're trying to be edgy!" I dislike it, Death for characters was something you can't avoid no matter what you do as well which is just the final straw.

    Minor character or not she was a favourite of mine and one of the few characters I enjoyed having around. Unlike one particular character in Ep.2 whom was only introduced to be killed in the same episode. Knew that one going in but damn that sucked for sure. I get it's a zombie game and it's meant to be bleak but you gotta be able to enjoy the game a bit too. I enjoyed and got immersed with the Carley and Lee relationship that was blossoming. Then I got brought down to reality by the fact that I'm playing a zombie game and the obvious thing to do was kill one of them.

    The people saying we're basically all playing the same storyline now make good points, too.
  • I think the fact that we all feel so strongly about Carley dying is a testament to how well these games are written. Episode 2 left me shaken when I finished it but this was the first episode I actually had to stop playing midway through because of how hard it hit me. I'm kind of scared for the next episode because I'm not sure I could take it if something happened to Clem.
  • PanStrife;660844 said:
    There's not a single positive thing in the game anymore.... I enjoyed and got immersed with the Carley and Lee relationship that was blossoming.
    What about Clem?

    I agree that happiness is hard to come by in the game anymore. There's not much to look forward to anymore beyond protecting Clem, for me.
This discussion has been closed.