User Avatar Image

So... about the St. John's Brothers

posted by Brohan on - last edited - Viewed by 1.4K users
Who actually killed them/ let them live? And why? :p

I killed Danny because he is a sick fuck. thinking Lee's group will eat him after he is killed, and I killed Andy because she pulled Clementine's hair, & like in the trailer Lee said "... is gonna end up dead."
25 Comments - Linear Discussion: Classic Style
  • I didn't kill Danny because he wasn't a threat anymore. I killed Andy because he still was.
  • On my original playthrough I didn't kill either. But on my second and third playthrough I did. Both of Andy's death scenes are pretty awesome (in a epic-movie-death-scene sort of way). Which ones have you seen and which one did you think was better? Lee kicking Andy into the fence or grabbing the gun and executing him?
  • KMatt;688726 said:
    On my original playthrough I didn't kill either. But on my second and third playthrough I did. Both of Andy's death scenes are pretty awesome (in a epic-movie-death-scene sort of way). Which ones have you seen and which one did you think was better? Lee kicking Andy into the fence or grabbing the gun and executing him?
    I tried this too in my other save file. I like the idea of him dying by his own creation. I also love the look Lilly gives you if you kill Andy.
  • Zeruis;688737 said:
    I tried this too in my other save file. I like the idea of him dying by his own creation. I also love the look Lilly gives you if you kill Andy.
    Yeah and if you'd just helped Kenny kill her father too, that makes you feel all kinds of bad.
  • KMatt;688756 said:
    Yeah and if you'd just helped Kenny kill her father too, that makes you feel all kinds of bad.
    Which is why I'm glad I decided to spare Andy at the very end. And I think shooting him is the better one, because Lee yells one final time as he steadies the rifle: "IT'S OVER!"
  • Rock114;688781 said:
    Which is why I'm glad I decided to spare Andy at the very end. And I think shooting him is the better one, because Lee yells one final time as he steadies the rifle: "IT'S OVER!"
    Yeah that is pretty awesome. I havn't enjoyed a game as much as I'm enjoying this game in a very long time. The writers are top-notch and the voice acting is perfect.

    Really looking forward to the next episode.
  • I left them both alive.

    After what just went down in that meat locker, I was still feeling pretty disturbed so I couldn't bring myself to off Danny in cold blood. Like Lee says, 'That's not how the world works now.'

    The same went for Andy, although I did beat him to a pulp (because at that point my shock had turned to anger, but I still was never going to kill him). The moment that music started playing though and Andy had resigned to his fate actually made me sad.
    I never thought I'd feel sad for the bad guys in a game like this.
  • RedKoolLoops;688799 said:
    I left them both alive.

    After what just went down in that meat locker, I was still feeling pretty disturbed so I couldn't bring myself to off Danny in cold blood. Like Lee says, 'That's not how the world works now.'

    The same went for Andy, although I did beat him to a pulp (because at that point my shock had turned to anger, but I still was never going to kill him). The moment that music started playing though and Andy had resigned to his fate actually made me sad.
    I never thought I'd feel sad for the bad guys in a game like this.
    it is pretty disturbing hearing someone that hates you ask you to kill them, i first noticed that in system shock 2 :)

    actually they both wanted to die, maybe they were deep down appalled at what they had become and just wanted it to end
  • Well I killed Danny, but I left Andy alive to suffer with the knowledge that his entire family was dead in one night.

    FOR MARK!
  • Danny was incapacitated and no threat so I left him, hoping Lilly would do it for me. I seriously considered killing Andy because grabbing Clem pissed me off, instead I just beat him to a pulp, told him both his family were dead and left him for zombiefood.
This discussion has been closed.