User Avatar Image

Which St.John brothers did you kill?

posted by Willzy123 on - last edited - Viewed by 1.5K users
Which St.John brothers did you kill?
41 Comments - Linear Discussion: Classic Style
  • Killed Danny. For MARK!

    Spared Andy so he could suffer knowing I killed his family.
  • I killed neither as Clementine reacted really badly when I killed Larry, and I didn't want to put the friendship on the line, so I left them.
  • aperose;713805 said:
    killed them both. in a way it was probably better than keeping them alive to get eaten by their zombie mother or risk them escaping and seeking revenge...plus the second one got the jump on me and I didn't get to beat him up :(
    Took the words away from me. Same here.:)
  • surprisingly, neither. If you killed Danny, Clementine would have watched, and that's not what I want her to remember me as. So not Danny. Andy, EVERYONE was watching. I just left him behind for the walkers. That part was so emotional, with the rain falling, and the music, Andy calling Lee's name, Lee yelling "IT'S OVER!". That part was written so well. I looked into his sad, pathetic beaten in face and I just couldn't do it. I wanted him to rot in the fact that I ruined his life, and just leave him for the herd.
  • Left them both for walkers
  • I finished the life of both. After the things they did to living people, I couldn't let them live. They were even a bigger threat than the zombies.
  • Psyconix;757759 said:
    I finished the life of both. After the things they did to living people, I couldn't let them live. They were even a bigger threat than the zombies.
    Exactly what I thought....
  • First time; killed Danny, spared Andy,
    Second time; spared Danny, killed Andy.
  • I impaled Danny with that pitchfork, thinking I'd done the right thing, until I saw it horrified Clementine. I then felt very guilty about it, and spared Andy's life to try and set a better example (though I did still beat the shit out of his face).
  • in my first playthrough i though Danny had to die, so i killed him, but seeing Clems reaction kept me thinking if vengeance was worth it, so on my second playthrough i let him get eaten by walkers. I won't risk what Clem thinks of me for someone who's no threat anymore and dead anyways. killing Larry was bad enough allready.
    Andy wasn't worth it, he was done. (i still did beat the shit out of his face too)
    so in the end i killed neither one of 'em.
This discussion has been closed.