Who did you feed?

I'm not sure if someone has posted this before but in episode 2 I gave food to Clem (of course who wouldn't), Duck because he is a child and needs to keep his strength up, Kenny because I have his back and he has mine and Ben believe it or not, because I felt sorry for him because his friend died and probably most of his group and he lost his camp. I didn't feed Larry because the man punched me in the last episode and left me for the walkers, I didn't feed Lily because I didn't like her at the time, I tried to give Carley food but she refused, I didn't feed Mark and I have no reason, I have no reason to not feed Katjaa and I didn't save food for myself because I didn't want to be greedy. So I was wondering who you fed and why and who you didn't feed and why.

Comments

  • edited May 2013
    I did the exact same things you did, even trying to feed Carley. Mostly for the same reasons too, although for Ben it wasn't so much that I felt sorry for him, so much as it was a process of elimination. Mark seemed like a gossip when he told Larry what I thought of him, I had already fed Kenny and Duck so I didn't want to just give all the food to one family, Carley wouldn't take it, and I didn't trust Lilly or Larry. So I gave Ben the food just because he was an unknown at the time, and by showing kindess now, I thought that there would be less chance for him to stab us in the back later on.

    Really wishing I'd given that jerky to Mark now.
  • edited May 2013
    I fed Clementine enough said, I fed duck and Kenny because we are bros and he is a nice kid, and Carley for saving me in the drug store, by luck I gave her the apple on the first try.
  • edited May 2013
    Clemmy and Duck. Kids first. Then Mark and Larry. Kept nuetral ground.
  • edited May 2013
    Clem, Duck, Kenny, and Mark.
  • edited May 2013
    I originally fed Clementine and Duck because not feeding the kids is just dickish, tried to feed Carley but she refused, fed Larry to try and prevent Lily from b!tching out at me, and fed Ben because I figured he hadn't gotten much to eat out in the wilderness.

    My second time through the game, I still fed Clem and Duck, managed to get Carley to accept food, and fed Mark since I figured a guy about to die might as well get a last meal. What with knowing how later episodes would end up, there was no way I was going to bother trying to keep Lily or Ben happy that time.
  • edited May 2013
    Clem, Duck, Kenny, and Mark. If I could give all the food to Clem, I would have.
  • edited May 2013
    I think, in one of the Playing Dead videos, it had the stats of who got fed in the group. Clementine won, of course, but apparently 3% of people actually didn't give her food. I'm pretty sure Duck was next.
  • edited May 2013
    I'll always feed:
    Clem - gotta take care of mah girl Clemmy
    Duck - brownie points for kenny and everyone approves
    Carley - besides Lee crushin' on her, it's good to keep your best shot fed

    I'll never feed:
    Larry - He tried to kill Lee at the pharmacy, maybe if he has less energy he won't escalate every situation into an argument.
    Ben - I never thought that kid would make it to ep. 5, but he's still brand new to the group so I wouldn't feed him over the others

    I'll usually go with either Kenny or Mark for that last piece of food, I gave some to Lilly on my first play through before I knew she was boarding the train to crazy town.
  • edited May 2013
    Duck- Clem - Ben - Mark
  • edited May 2013
    Thanks for replying everyone, your choices are interesting and I was surprised that Rock114 chose the exact same thing as me. I look forward to reading more posts.
  • edited May 2013
    Rock114 wrote: »
    I think, in one of the Playing Dead videos, it had the stats of who got fed in the group. Clementine won, of course, but apparently 3% of people actually didn't give her food. I'm pretty sure Duck was next.

    I saw that too in fact I have the stats right here: 96% gave Clem food, 95% gave Duck food, 58% gave Mark food, 42% gave Larry food, 33% gave Kenny food, 29% gave Lilly food, 19% gave Ben food, 15% gave Carley food, 11% kept food for them self and 3% gave food to Doug. Poor Doug.
  • edited May 2013
    I fed Clementine, Duck, Kenny, and Larry. Tried to keep as neutral as possible.
  • edited May 2013
    Thanks for replying everyone, your choices are interesting and I was surprised that Rock114 chose the exact same thing as me. I look forward to reading more posts.

    Well, don't actually be so surprised. I'm Team Kenny to the end.
  • edited May 2013
    RichWalk23 wrote: »
    I fed Clementine, Duck, Kenny, and Larry. Tried to keep as neutral as possible.

    Exactly the same here, reasons and all. I tried to feed Carley but already used the apple.
  • edited May 2013
    yay go team Kenny, better then any other use of team in any media especially Twilight.
  • edited May 2013
    Rock114 wrote: »
    Well, don't actually be so surprised. I'm Team Kenny to the end.

    Go team Kenny! Anyway I was surprised because Ben seemed like an unpopular choice because he was new and most of the group didn't trust him so I thought that not many people would have given him food. Turns out I was wrong.
  • edited May 2013
    always the kids ,so Clem first always,then Duck right away,these kids are depending on the adults to look after them and Lee can deal with moaning hungry group members,and it's not like a apple not given to someone will start ww3,so Kids come first!...then...i never pick Ben,i figure a 16-19 year old can look after himself like an adult lol so i usually either pick either Lily or Kenny depending on which playthrough im siding on,and i never feed Mark either,and keep the last piece of food for myself:D
  • edited May 2013
    The other day that I was playing it I gave the cheese and crackers to Clementine and Duck and I gave the beef jerky to Mark(or is it Marv?)and the half orange to Larry.Just in case he appreciates it.
  • edited June 2013
    I fed Clem , Duck , Mark and Kenny

    The kids because of obvious reasons their KIDS

    Kenny cause Team Kenny till the End

    Mark cause i tought he was a cool guy
  • edited June 2013
    I fed Lilly, Carley, Clem & Duck. :D
  • edited June 2013
    On my last play-through, I fed Clem, Duck, Kenny, and Ben, in that order.
  • edited June 2013
    In order
    1. Clementine: Apple
    2. Duck: Cheese and crackers
    3. Carley: (attempted) Cheese and crackers
    4. Katjaa: (attempted) Cheese and crackers
    5. Kenny: Cheese and crackers
    6. Larry: Beef jerky
  • edited June 2013
    Rock114 wrote: »
    Clementine won, of course, but apparently 3% of people actually didn't give her food.

    I am the 3%! It wasn't anything masochistic, the people who were gathering food were getting weak and if they didn't keep going then nobody was going to eat, children included.
  • edited June 2013
    TygerTyger wrote: »
    I am the 3%! It wasn't anything masochistic, the people who were gathering food were getting weak and if they didn't keep going then nobody was going to eat, children included.

    A valid reason.

    Still, you better get off this thread before the angry mob forms. I can already hear them grabbing pitchforks.
  • edited June 2013
    You might want to start running, I can here the mob coming closer every minute.
  • edited June 2013
    I just came on to my thread to see the new replies and I see that TygerTyger didn't feed Clem. You son of... I'm joking but you should probably take bioshock infinite WD and Rock114 advice and start running before the angry mob come. I'm not angry at you it seems you have a good reason I just don't agree with letting a little girl starve while others get to eat. Clem will always be my first choice. But it's your choice.
  • edited June 2013
    As long as you like Clementine then you will live but if not then I am surprised someone does not have your head, I understand your reason and it makes since so no hate here.
This discussion has been closed.