This discussion may contain spoilers!
I think the big choices that are gonna have an impact later on in the stories were whether or not you gave Faith money, how you handled the Beauty and the Beast situation, if you went to Toad's or Lawrence's first, who you chose to go after in the bar, whether or not you maimed Grendel, and who you thought was the main suspect. Why did you choose the choices you chose?
Here are my picks:
Faith: I gave money to Faith, didn't want her to get into trouble with her pimp. Didn't really matter in the end, though. Seeing her head on the stairs was pretty damn surprising.
Beauty and Beast: I also lied to Beast. I didn't want to, but I promised Beauty I'd cover for her. Which I immidiately regreted. I don't lie, but I don't break promises either, so...it was kind of a tricky situation.
Toad and Lawrence: I went to Toad's apartment first, because it sounded like he was in pretty big trouble. Plus, he and Bigby seem friendly, sort of. I was just curious to see where that'd lead later on.
Woody or Dee: I went after Dee. Woody, even though he's a doucheag, he's not that kind of an animal. He definitely didn't kill Faith. I'm not sayind Dee did it, but he can definitely point me in the right direction to find out who did.
Prime Suspect: No one. I kept quiet, didn't really know what to say.
Grendel: I didn't rip off his arm. I would have, but I think that's gonna be a pretty important development in my relationship with Woody later on.